Name: STARRY EYES am9 to pm9 GEL EYELINER [06 MATT BLACK]
Brand: lilybyred
Rating: 4.12 (78 reviews)

Rich and earthy shades like mustard yellow, olive green, and chocolate brown look great on you

How to Write a TikTok Review
 Help us keep the Hwahae community trustworthy by following these guidelines: 
Reviews that violate these may be removed without notice.

Bright and fresh shades like coral, warm pinks, and fresh greens look great on you

Soft and muted shades like pastel blues, dusty pinks, and soft lavenders look great on you

High-contrast and bold shades like pure white, black, icy blues, and deep reds look great on you

I confirm this is my own TikTok video and agree it maybe featured on Hwahae.
 Any misuse may result in removal or restrictions.
 For details, tap the

Our service will be temporarily unavailable during:

Scheduled Maintenance

Each product allows one tiktok video review and one text review

This is a Health Functional Food certified by the Ministry of Food and Drug Safety (MFDS) of Korea, designed to help maintain and improve your health.

This review was written by The Hwahae Testers who received the product for free and evaluated it with a sense of representing Hwahae. The review is completely unbiased and honest, with no guidelines or restrictions.

Reviews by The Hwahae Testers undergo the same strict verification process as regular reviews, and if they don't meet our standards, revisions will be requested.

Each ingredient is selected for its specific purpose, such as improving skin hydration or brightening. However, the inclusion of these ingredients does not guarantee the overall effectiveness of the final product. Simply using these ingredients does not ensure the product will deliver the claimed benefits.

AI-Analyzed Reviews are coming soon!
We're gathering more reviews to provide you with the best insights.

Be the first to share your experience!
Used this product?
Share your TikTok review to help others discover it.

The content is currently being reviewed by the Hwahae operations team, and the verification will be completed by the next business day (excluding weekends and holidays) from the date the review was written.

Help us keep the Hwahae community trustworthy by following these guidelines.
Reviews that don’t follow the standards may be removed without notice.

Reviews that don’t follow the guidelines may be removed without prior notice.

Tell us about what you liked - texture, results, skin type, etc

Tell us what didn’t work - texture, skin reaction, or why you wouldn’t recommend it

릴리바이레드

STARRY EYES am9 to pm9 GEL EYELINER [06 MATT BLACK]

Matte Finish

Smudges

Rubs Off

Not Vivid

Feels Harsh on Skin

Dark Brown-Toned

Not Silver-Toned

Long-Lasting

Easy to Apply

Doesn't Smudge Easily

Easy to Draw

Bold

Accentuates

Creamy

It tends to smudge a bit. I don't think I'll repurchase it.

It absorbs well and the price is reasonable. I bought it out of curiosity.

스태리아이즈 나인투나인 젤 아이라이너 [06 매트블랙]

For someone who prefers a really thin eyeliner, it feels a bit blunt even when sharpened to the max.

It's better for filling in the waterline than creating a wing. Applies smoothly and offers great value for money.

I recommend storing the pen upright overnight for best results

The pen tip is too thick, making it very difficult to draw precise eyeliner

It absorbs smoothly and is great for creating bold eyeliner looks

The soft texture makes it challenging to draw precise lines, and it tends to smudge, so caution is needed when applying.

The color is vibrant and it absorbs beautifully. The generous amount lasts for a long time.

I prefer drawing thin eyeliner, but the pencil is too thick, so I have to apply it to a separate eyeliner brush to draw. Also, the color payoff decreases the more you use it. The formula is quite soft, so be careful as it breaks easily!

There's absolutely no smudging and the staying power is incredible. It was definitely great when I first got it.

Instead of sharpening a thick pencil, I'd recommend buying a slim liner to avoid the hassle. Sharpening this product reduces its volume, so it's better to opt for a slim liner that starts out thin but has less product overall.

It's not extremely dark black, which is a bit disappointing. If you dispense too much product, it's prone to breaking, but if you use less, it tends to stick to the opening and transfer to the skin around your eyes. While the staying power is good, it's not perfect and fades a bit. It tends to dry out with prolonged use. Towards the end, you don't get that initial smooth application.

I'd give it 4.5 stars. Great value for money in terms of quantity and quality. It comes with a built-in sharpener, though I don't use it. The color is quite black. It feels nice to use and has good staying power. No smudging. Glides on smoothly. The auto-format makes it convenient to use. The thickness is just right for me, as I like to draw wider eyeliner.

The color is so intense that even a small amount results in heavy makeup. The most frustrating thing... Pencil eyeliners need to be sharpened, but something's wrong. I've barely used it, and the eyeliner has already separated. What I mean is, the wooden part you hold and the inner eyeliner core have come apart. The inner core keeps moving around, making it incredibly difficult to apply. I don't know if it's defective or if the product is supposed to be like this... I just kept using it because I didn't want to waste money. I've been using pencil eyeliners for 10 years, and I've never seen anything like this before. I wonder how they expect people to use this.

The absorbs well is decent. The eyeliner glides on quickly. It's great for those who want to create a bold eye look. The black color is incredibly intense.

It breaks way too easily! I dropped it once, and the inside was completely shattered. Considering it's not exactly cheap, I decided to switch to something else.

I tried this after seeing recommendations online, and its long-lasting formula was definitely the standout feature. Plus, the thin tip makes it super easy to control!

It's perfect if you just use a brush-tip liner for the outer corners!

The tip isn't sharp enough, making it a bit challenging to draw the outer corners of the eyes. Also, when removing it, it tends to get a bit clumpy and takes a while to come off. You absolutely need to do a pre-cleanse before your regular face wash. Otherwise, you'll end up with panda eyes even after washing!

I usually avoid eyeliner pencils because they smudge, but this one is smudge-resistant. That alone makes it worth recommending! I used to only use brush-tip liners, but now I'm using this alongside them.

I can't really think of any downsides. It's just great overall!

The staying power and how it absorbs are top-notch! It was even better because it came as a buy-one-get-one-free deal.

It's a bit too thick, so I think I'll need to use it alongside a slimmer pencil. It feels wasteful to keep sharpening it every day.

While it's not ideal for the outer corners of the eyes, it's great for filling in thicker areas smoothly, like the waterline. The staying power is also quite decent.

The downside is that when removing it, traces of eyeliner remain visible on my eyes. It gives me an uneasy feeling, like it might stain my skin.

First off, I love how creamy it feels when applied! It's great that it dries quickly and doesn't smudge onto my eyelids.

For the wing, it's better to use a different product or create the shape with a cotton swab or your nail. This technique actually improves the longevity!

The downside is that because it's so soft, it wears down quickly. But I suppose it's better to use it all up than have it break off...

It glides on so smoothly when filling in the waterline. Unlike others that break off or come out clumpy, this one applies perfectly in a true black shade. It has better staying power than others and doesn't smudge easily on the waterline. I've finally found my holy grail!

Korean Reviews

STARRY EYES am9 to pm9 GEL EYELINER [06 MATT BLACK]

3 Reviews