Name: STARRY EYES am9 to pm9 SLIM GEL EYELINER [05# CARAMEL BROWN]
Brand: lilybyred
Rating: 4.35 (26 reviews)

Rich and earthy shades like mustard yellow, olive green, and chocolate brown look great on you

How to Write a TikTok Review
 Help us keep the Hwahae community trustworthy by following these guidelines: 
Reviews that violate these may be removed without notice.

Bright and fresh shades like coral, warm pinks, and fresh greens look great on you

Soft and muted shades like pastel blues, dusty pinks, and soft lavenders look great on you

High-contrast and bold shades like pure white, black, icy blues, and deep reds look great on you

I confirm this is my own TikTok video and agree it maybe featured on Hwahae.
 Any misuse may result in removal or restrictions.
 For details, tap the

Our service will be temporarily unavailable during:

Scheduled Maintenance

Each product allows one tiktok video review and one text review

This is a Health Functional Food certified by the Ministry of Food and Drug Safety (MFDS) of Korea, designed to help maintain and improve your health.

This review was written by The Hwahae Testers who received the product for free and evaluated it with a sense of representing Hwahae. The review is completely unbiased and honest, with no guidelines or restrictions.

Reviews by The Hwahae Testers undergo the same strict verification process as regular reviews, and if they don't meet our standards, revisions will be requested.

Each ingredient is selected for its specific purpose, such as improving skin hydration or brightening. However, the inclusion of these ingredients does not guarantee the overall effectiveness of the final product. Simply using these ingredients does not ensure the product will deliver the claimed benefits.

AI-Analyzed Reviews are coming soon!
We're gathering more reviews to provide you with the best insights.

Be the first to share your experience!
Used this product?
Share your TikTok review to help others discover it.

The content is currently being reviewed by the Hwahae operations team, and the verification will be completed by the next business day (excluding weekends and holidays) from the date the review was written.

Help us keep the Hwahae community trustworthy by following these guidelines.
Reviews that don’t follow the standards may be removed without notice.

Reviews that don’t follow the guidelines may be removed without prior notice.

Tell us about what you liked - texture, results, skin type, etc

Tell us what didn’t work - texture, skin reaction, or why you wouldn’t recommend it

릴리바이레드

STARRY EYES am9 to pm9 SLIM GEL EYELINER [05# CARAMEL BROWN]

Pills on Skin

Smudges

Absorbs Well

Smudges Easily

Soft

Looks Natural

Has Good Color

Brown-Toned

Easy to Draw

Has a Shading Effect

Easy to Apply

Not sure if it's possible, but I wish it was a bit slimmer.

I like the smooth texture. It's a light brown shade, which is exactly what I needed.

스태리아이즈 나인투나인 슬림 젤 아이라이너 [05# 카라멜브라운]

I wish there were more color options available. It would be great if they offered the same range of colors as the regular Staryeyes line.

I prefer drawing subtle eyeliner. I've been using the regular Staryeyes, but I decided to try the slim version. It definitely draws a thinner line with precision! I'm really pleased with the color.

There's absolutely nothing bad to say... Well, the amount might be a bit small, but considering the price, it's still a great deal!

I was so sad when Clio's Shawshosim was discontinued in the Kakao Brown shade after its renewal... But finally, I've found a replacement! It's an incredibly light brown that's not too pale, striking a perfect balance. It's ideal for daily use, especially for those with lighter skin tones, makeup beginners, or anyone who prefers a more subtle look. The best part? It's super affordable too!

Since the color is subtle, you can softly blend it for versatile use on lip lines, aegyo-sal, and even as an eyeliner. It's quite versatile!

After using it for a while, it somehow doesn't apply as smoothly... The reddish tint might be hit or miss for some people.

It's great for a light application! Gently blending the edges creates a lovely natural makeup look. I even dab a bit under my eyes for a subtle aegyo-sal shadow effect.

Like most slim eyeliners, the product quantity is on the smaller side.

It's thin, making it easy to draw. I love the color payoff, staying power, and shade range!

For me, it seems to smudge a bit and darkens the area under my eyes

I love how smoothly it applies and the color isn't too intense

For those worried about the amount, there's a standard gel liner available in the same color, so consider purchasing that as well!

The only slight drawback is that it's a bit soft, and because of the small amount, it runs out quickly... However, the advantages of the slim version are so great that I keep both a thick one and this one on hand!

The delicate color is perfect for creating a natural makeup look! I love that there are both slim and standard versions available, giving you options to choose from.

Unfortunately, it didn't apply as boldly as I'd hoped, possibly due to the oiliness around my eyes

The slim design made it great for drawing a natural-looking eyeliner

I think I've found my holy grail product. It's perfect for both a no-makeup makeup look and a natural everyday style. I can see myself using this daily.

The color is absolutely gorgeous! It's even better than Clio at nailing the perfect shade. When I use this instead of a heavy eyeliner, it gives such a feminine, natural, and beautiful look. I tried it on at Olive Young before buying, and I'm impressed by how it doesn't smudge even when rubbed. The staying power is excellent too!

If you're looking for a natural-looking eyeliner, give this one a try! The swatch on my hand might look a bit dark because I applied more pressure, but when you gently apply it to your eyes, it creates a beautifully natural color.

The tip is a bit blunt, making it slightly challenging to create a sharp wing... However, I believe the overall quality of the product more than makes up for this minor issue. I'm willing to overlook it because the eyeliner is that good!

I've finally found my holy grail eyeliner... After struggling to find the lightest, most natural brown shade among pencil gel liners, I decided to give this product a try, and wow, the color is absolutely perfect! It applies lightly for a truly natural look with one stroke, but you can build it up for a more intense makeup look by layering. This product is the real deal. I've tried similar formulas from other brands before, but they dried too quickly while applying, making it painful and difficult to use. However, this one doesn't dry out and glides on smoothly every time. It's truly my holy grail. I'm so happy. Please, Lilybyred team, don't ever discontinue this shade!

I'm not sure if it's just me, but it smudges way too quickly. After about 3 hours, it migrates down below the triangle zone...

I love this new sleep version of the Nine to Nine line! It's the same color as before but even thinner, which is fantastic. The shade looks so gentle and not too flashy, making it perfect for everyday use.

Korean Reviews

STARRY EYES am9 to pm9 SLIM GEL EYELINER [05# CARAMEL BROWN]

2 Reviews