Name: Artist Formula Cream Liner [04 Gold Harmony]
Brand: colorgram
Rating: 4.67 (18 reviews)

Rich and earthy shades like mustard yellow, olive green, and chocolate brown look great on you

How to Write a TikTok Review
 Help us keep the Hwahae community trustworthy by following these guidelines: 
Reviews that violate these may be removed without notice.

Bright and fresh shades like coral, warm pinks, and fresh greens look great on you

Soft and muted shades like pastel blues, dusty pinks, and soft lavenders look great on you

High-contrast and bold shades like pure white, black, icy blues, and deep reds look great on you

I confirm this is my own TikTok video and agree it maybe featured on Hwahae.
 Any misuse may result in removal or restrictions.
 For details, tap the

Our service will be temporarily unavailable during:

Scheduled Maintenance

This is a Health Functional Food certified by the Ministry of Food and Drug Safety (MFDS) of Korea, designed to help maintain and improve your health.

This review was written by a Hwahae Trial Reviewer who received the product for free and evaluated it with a sense of representing Hwahae. The review is completely unbiased and honest, with no guidelines or restrictions.

Trial Reviewers' reviews undergo the same strict verification process as regular reviews, and if they don't meet our standards, revisions will be requested.

Each ingredient is selected for its specific purpose, such as improving skin hydration or brightening. However, the inclusion of these ingredients does not guarantee the overall effectiveness of the final product. Simply using these ingredients does not ensure the product will deliver the claimed benefits.

AI-Analyzed Reviews are coming soon!
We're gathering more reviews to provide you with the best insights.

Be the first to share your experience!
Used this product?
Share your TikTok review to help others discover it.

The content is currently being reviewed by the Hwahae operations team, and the verification will be completed by the next business day (excluding weekends and holidays) from the date the review was written.

컬러그램

Artist Formula Cream Liner [04 Gold Harmony]

Smudges

Clumps

Soft

Poor Pigmentation

Smudges Easily

Has Shimmer

Gold-Toned

Has a Shading Effect

Easy to Apply

Lasts Long

Not Irritating

Lightweight

🌸Downside🌸
When applied too thickly, it tends to crease a bit with the aegyo-sal eyeshadow, so I'll need to be careful with the application.

🌸One-line Review After Use🌸
This warm eyeliner was good to use as an aegyo-sal base.
🌸Reviewer's Skin Type🌸
Extremely dry and sensitive, prone to smudging.
🌸Review After Use🌸
I tried using this eyeliner as an aegyo-sal base since it's known for good lasting power. As the name 'Gold Harmony' suggests, the gold color showed up nicely, giving a warm finish.
The lasting power was really good.

아티스트 포뮬라 크림라이너 [04 골드하모니]

It wasn't as glamorous as I expected, a light gold..? But it was still great for daily use on the aegyo-sal! However, it breaks easily ㅠ I broke the very end part as soon as I got it.

It's so gorgeous, the best for warm-toned people.
And wow, the staying power is really amazing - no matter how much I rub it, it just won't come off. How does the pearl not budge...? I applied it to my hand and rubbed, but there was no change. It's beautiful, has great staying power, and is the best.!.!.!
When you remove the cap, the sharpener comes out with it.

There's nothing particularly disappointing, but the rotating part is prone to getting damaged when carrying it around in a pouch.

It has great value for money! It sets right away, so the longevity is better than expected! I can use it to lightly draw on the eyelid instead of eyeshadow

If you don't control the amount properly, it can easily break
You need to only twist it as much as you need
If you use it hastily, it can look clumped and like an excessive makeup look, so you need to be careful

1) It's great to focus on the eyelid crease
2) It's lightweight and convenient to carry around
3) The built-in sharpener allows me to sharpen it and create thin lines, which I really like

The downside is that since it's a pencil type, it tends to clump up a bit. So after applying, I have to use my fingers to smooth it out. And over time, I can feel it settling into the fine lines. Also, the product quantity is on the smaller side, so I have to replace it more frequently.

This is my favorite eye makeup item for the spring season.
To begin with, my skin tone is very yellow, and pink shades do not suit my face at all. However, colors with a strong yellow undertone can make my skin look dull. That's why this product was perfect for me. While it has a golden hue, it doesn't look dull and instead brightens up the under-eye area beautifully. Additionally, it has good staying power, so I use it as a daily essential.

If I really had to nitpick, it would be the volume...? Other than that, there's absolutely nothing wrong with it!!!!! No matter how much I look, I can't find any flaws!

1. Beautiful
You all really should buy this. It's a product that's great for daily use, naturally adding a glossy, vaseline-like effect to your aegyo-sal. At school, my friends are always trying to steal it from me. The color is also a natural-looking gold that doesn't stand out too much.

2. Convenience
It's thin, so it's easy to use on small areas, and I used to worry about shimmer eyeshadow making a mess, but I've never had that problem with this product.

3. Cost-effectiveness
I bought it at Olive Young for around 4,000 won! They say the volume is small, but since I don't use a lot each time, I'm extremely satisfied.

It's not available, I dropped it on the floor and it broke, so be careful not to drop it.

It has a subtle and beautiful glow. I thought it would have a yellowish tint, but that feeling is not really there. It applies smoothly.

If you apply too much, it just makes the area under your eyes sparkly, which isn't great.. You have to apply it moderately to look pretty.

It's so pretty haha! If you apply it to your cheeks, it's really pretty. I'd recommend it more for warm-toned people than cool-toned people.

After drawing aegyo-sal with an eyebrow pencil, just apply this on top of the aegyo-sal area and you're done... I love it so much!!

The only downside is that it's a bit thin, so you have to be careful not to easily break it? Other than that, there's nothing else wrong with it at all..

Wow.. I don't even know what to say, it's just so good. There's really nothing like this when it comes to emphasizing aegyo-sal. It's not over-the-top at all, it just perfectly accentuates the aegyo-sal, making my eyes look so bright and radiant!! I actually bought this based on the color, and this shade is the most beautiful and natural-looking. I highly recommend it..

 I'll definitely purchase it during sales!!
Even at the original price, the value is about the same as other products, so it's worth it. Haha

 There isn't one yet.
Even though you mentioned the price, it's usually around this range, so it's okay.
However, since it's a gel pencil, it wears down quickly, so I'll probably only purchase it during sales.

 🥰I've found the perfect eyeshadow color for my life!🥰

To be honest, I didn't have a very good impression of color cosmetics before. I had purchased various tints in the past, but none of them were my type. Then, I saw that Olive Young was having a sale on eyeliners, and there was a color I wanted, so I decided to give it a try.

To start with the results, ⭐⭐this choice is satisfactory⭐⭐.

I purchased 4 colors (No. 4 Gold Harmony, No. 5 Choco Brown, No. 6 Coral Brown, No. 8 Creamy Brown).

⭐Common Points

❤Ingredients
I was surprised to find that the ingredients are good, as I usually don't pay much attention to the ingredients when purchasing color cosmetics.

❤Texture
It applies smoothly!! Sometimes, even with a pencil, it can be difficult to apply and make the eye area red, but this one is good.

❤Lasting Power
If you smudge it right after applying, it blends smoothly. After it sets, there's no smudging (not as strong as waterproof, but good for daily use).

⭐Advantages of this Product

❤Color
I usually like thick and shimmery pearls, but this product has a beige color with fine gold pearls that sparkle subtly.
※※※※※Picture
My hands are darker than my face, so it's not very noticeable, but when applied to the eyelids, it really shines.

❤Natural Volume
It's not too much, and it's a really pretty color for daily use, like for going to work. 👩‍⚖👩‍⚖👩‍⚖ Ding ding ding

❤Luxurious Feel!!!!
The quality feels luxurious for the price.

If you apply it with other large glitters on the aegyo-sal, it looks pretty.

They say it has good staying power, but it smudges.
I'm anxious while using it because it seems like it might break.

There was something that could be shaved in the back, so it was convenient.
It was applied smoothly and could be cut without irritation.

I'm really particular about my aegyo sal, so I like to apply this thinly on the front part and then use a matching point color in the center. And using the same line's 09 soft brown color to draw on the aegyo sal gives such a fantastic effect - it's like a pumping bang! Come check out my review for the 09 shade too. Bye bye!

If you apply too much, it can get a bit patchy and uneven. And I wouldn't recommend using it on the mucous membranes - it doesn't apply well and is too thick, so you might accidentally poke your eye.

I bought it because it was 1+1, and oh my, I love it so much. I actually bought it to fill in my mucous membranes, but the pencil is too thick and doesn't apply well for that purpose. So I used it on my aegyo sal, and it's so pretty! As a creamy type pencil, it applies smoothly and doesn't irritate my sensitive aegyo sal area at all! The color is just amazing - it's a champagne color with fine gold pearls, so it really makes my aegyo sal look plump and glowing when I apply it. And it's not as metallic as a silver highlighter, which I really like. I've been raving about it everywhere, so it's perfect for a makeup look that wants to emphasize the eyes.