I've tried Kiss Me's eyeliner, eyebrow color, and mascara, but I never expected their eyebrow pencil to be this good! Kiss Me really excels in eye makeup, that's for sure! I was previously using Clio's ash brown eyebrow product, and while they're similar in many ways, there are differences in texture and thickness. In terms of texture, Clio's is a bit more matte, while Kiss Me's is softer. This comes down to personal preference depending on your skin type. While both have good staying power, I felt Kiss Me's was more intense and lasted even longer. Both have a hexagonal shape, making them easy to use, and they come with a built-in brush and sharpener, which is super convenient! But I noticed a difference in the brush details. Kiss Me's brush is thinner and slightly curved, making it feel more user-friendly. Also, Kiss Me's pencil is slightly thinner than Clio's, making it better for creating fine, hair-like strokes.
There's talk about it not applying well on bare skin, but I applied it over makeup and found it went on smoothly. My slightly dry skin might have helped too. I'd recommend testing it before buying!
To sum up my recommendation: Clio is better for creating a softer look at the front of the brows, while Kiss Me is great for more defined, precise strokes, especially at the tail end of the brows.