It lives up to its reputation! The mascara goes on smoothly and has great staying power. I bought it when it came with a free tweezer, and I found that if you clump your lashes together after applying the mascara, it lifts them even more beautifully. I'm planning to buy the brown shade soon too.
There wasn't really anything disappointing about it! I just need to practice my eyelash curler skills more...
I recommend buying it when it comes with the free tweezer!