ProsAfter finishing my Clinique eyebrow pencil, I was contemplating whether to repurchase it or try something new. I decided to give this product a shot when I heard it came with a full-size No Smudge mascara as a gratis gift. While it's usually a bit pricey, I'm particularly satisfied as I got it at a great value thanks to this special offer. It feels quite similar to MAC's brow pencil in both shape and composition, but somehow it seems more... perfect? (Perhaps it's because of the product name 'Perfectly Defined'). I have natural black hair with a slight brown tint, so I chose Mahogany. Based on other reviews, Espresso might have been a good choice too. What I love most is the texture - it's neither too soft nor too hard, striking that perfect balance typical of a quality brow pencil. I need to buy an eyeliner next, and I'm considering sticking with the same brand.
ConsIt tends to fade a bit quickly if applied lightly. I'll probably need to apply it a little more heavily.
Recommended