Name: am9 to pm9 SURVIVAL PENLINER NATURAL [01 #Ash Black]
Brand: lilybyred
Rating: 4.3 (33 reviews)

Rich and earthy shades like mustard yellow, olive green, and chocolate brown look great on you

How to Write a TikTok Review
 Help us keep the Hwahae community trustworthy by following these guidelines: 
Reviews that violate these may be removed without notice.

Bright and fresh shades like coral, warm pinks, and fresh greens look great on you

Soft and muted shades like pastel blues, dusty pinks, and soft lavenders look great on you

High-contrast and bold shades like pure white, black, icy blues, and deep reds look great on you

I confirm this is my own TikTok video and agree it maybe featured on Hwahae.
 Any misuse may result in removal or restrictions.
 For details, tap the

Our service will be temporarily unavailable during:

Scheduled Maintenance

Each product allows one tiktok video review and one text review

This is a Health Functional Food certified by the Ministry of Food and Drug Safety (MFDS) of Korea, designed to help maintain and improve your health.

This review was written by The Hwahae Testers who received the product for free and evaluated it with a sense of representing Hwahae. The review is completely unbiased and honest, with no guidelines or restrictions.

Reviews by The Hwahae Testers undergo the same strict verification process as regular reviews, and if they don't meet our standards, revisions will be requested.

Each ingredient is selected for its specific purpose, such as improving skin hydration or brightening. However, the inclusion of these ingredients does not guarantee the overall effectiveness of the final product. Simply using these ingredients does not ensure the product will deliver the claimed benefits.

AI-Analyzed Reviews are coming soon!
We're gathering more reviews to provide you with the best insights.

Be the first to share your experience!
Used this product?
Share your TikTok review to help others discover it.

The content is currently being reviewed by the Hwahae operations team, and the verification will be completed by the next business day (excluding weekends and holidays) from the date the review was written.

Help us keep the Hwahae community trustworthy by following these guidelines.
Reviews that don’t follow the standards may be removed without notice.

Reviews that don’t follow the guidelines may be removed without prior notice.

Tell us about what you liked - texture, results, skin type, etc

Tell us what didn’t work - texture, skin reaction, or why you wouldn’t recommend it

릴리바이레드

am9 to pm9 SURVIVAL PENLINER NATURAL [01 #Ash Black]

Poor Pigmentation

Not Olive-Toned

Heavy

Causes Itching

Poor Brush Quality

Pills on Skin

Clumps

Looks Natural

Soft

Lasts Long

Easy to Draw

Not Vivid

Feels Warm

Delicate

The staying power is a bit disappointing. After about 2 hours, it starts to feel itchy, and if you scratch it even lightly, it comes right off.

It's a watery, ash-tinted gray color that seems suitable for both warm and cool skin tones.

나인투나인 서바이벌 펜라이너 내추럴 [01 #애쉬블랙]

I didn't notice any downsides while using it. That's how pretty and good this product is!

On days when I want to look nice at school, this gives me a naturally pretty and delicate appearance. I think it would be great for those with fair skin too!

I'd rather buy Kiss Me or Wemakeup Ara instead of this. The brush split apart after barely any use, it leaks terribly, and the staying power is poor. I won't buy it again. This is the first time I've felt like I wasted my money

I liked the pretty color, but there were too many drawbacks for me to consider repurchasing

There's nothing particularly bad about it. It's just good. Maybe it's slightly more intense than a bare-faced look? If you're not into bold eyeliner, this is perfect for you.

I'm really enjoying using this product. It's not too intense or too light - it's just right. I absolutely love it!

The quantity is surprisingly generous and the color is truly beautiful. I definitely recommend it. It's great!

Highly recommended for those who don't suit bold eyeliners

I bought this to draw an inner corner eyeliner, but it applied a bit light at first. I found that applying about three layers gave me the perfect intensity without being too dark.

The staying power was impressive! It didn't smudge even when I rubbed my eyes. After it stained a bit, I tried washing it with water, and it held up pretty well. The color is absolutely gorgeous!

It comes off quite easily in my experience. If I rub my eyes just once, it's gone - it just disappears.

First off, highly recommended for those with fair skin tones. True to its name, the ash color is neither too intense nor too light, giving a natural and subtle look that I really appreciate. If you prefer bold colors, this might not be for you. It's perfect as a daily eyeliner. The thin pen tip allows for precise and neat application.

I'm using this product so well that I honestly can't find any downsides.

I don't suit heavy makeup, so I bought a light eyeliner and I'm absolutely thrilled with it!

If used as an eyeliner rather than for eyebrows, the color payoff is too intense and heavy-looking.

The ashy eyeliner is perfect for drawing eyebrows. It creates a very natural, hair-like effect and has excellent staying power.

If it keeps coming off due to pilling, just blend it with a dark brown eyeshadow to fill in the gaps. It won't be noticeable.

While it's not a film-type formula, it occasionally pills. It can be slightly removed by tears. Also, in the summer evenings, it tends to smudge a bit. That's why I use it for light makeup in summer, but opt for different products when I need my makeup to last longer.

I love the natural black color. When blended with brown eyeshadow, it has a strong presence without looking overdone. I've stopped using other products and now exclusively use this one.

The brush bristles tend to split a bit. Apart from that, the staying power is decent and everything else is great.

The color payoff is excellent and it applies beautifully. The ash tone is perfect for everyday wear.

Korean Reviews

am9 to pm9 SURVIVAL PENLINER NATURAL [01 #Ash Black]

Reviews