{"content_id":"1748373","content_type":"product"}
4.24
5
11
4
3
2
1
25
Reviews
- ho********Dry SkinSensitive SkinAcne SkinBrightening/Dark SpotsSebum/BlackheadsDark CirclesInner DrynessWrinkles/ElasticityEnlarged PoresRednessDead Skin CellsRecommendedDec 21, 2020
This is an absolute treasure for those with monolids! My eyeliner tends to smudge easily, but this one's a gem. It does seem to spread a bit, but if you apply eyeshadow over the liner, it smudges less. Shade 4 has such a beautiful color! I'd love to try other shades, but it's such a shame they've been discontinued. Skinfood really needs to bring this product back! It's truly an all-in-one eye product - you can use it for eyeliner, eyeshadow, and even eyebrows! The eyeliner tends to dry out quickly. Also, the brush could be a bit firmer. 
Hwahae UserCombination SkinSensitive SkinAcne SkinRecommendedNov 14, 2018Even though my eye makeup tends to smudge easily, this product barely smudges or doesn't smudge at all! It's even more smudge-proof when I apply eyeshadow, then eyeliner, and then another layer of eyeshadow. The best part is that it's still easy to remove during cleansing. I'm absolutely in love with it! The quality of the brush that comes with it is... well... It might be better to buy a separate eyeliner brush. I found that applying base eyeshadow, then drawing the eyeliner, and following up with point shadow along the eyeliner line not only prevents smudging but also improves the staying power! - il**********Combination SkinSensitive SkinAcne SkinRecommendedSep 30, 2018
Why does everyone say this product isn't good? For me, it was really great! The eyeliner's staying power is excellent. I was using Kiss Me before, but it smudged too much, so I thought I needed to get a new one. This item was a huge success! I went to see a movie and cried, but it barely smudged. Even during PE class, when I was sweating profusely, it didn't come off! The eyeshadow isn't particularly impressive... The powder fallout from the eyeshadow is intense! When I swatched it with my fingers, I thought, 'Oh, not much fallout.' But the moment I used a brush, powder went flying everywhere. The case is fragile. I'm not sure if it's just me, but the case is really weak. The lid on top just broke off easily. - Hwahae UserDry SkinSensitive SkinOct 18, 2017
This color cosmetic was designed specifically for the only eyeshadow palette I've seen. The eyeshadow colors are so beautiful, and the formula has a nice oil-controlling texture that makes it great for those with oily eyelids. The combo of the two shades is fantastic. It looks high-end and pretty. The eyeliner applies nicely with a brush and once it dries, it doesn't smudge without a remover, making it a godsend for those who struggle with smearing. But these days I just use the eyeshadows and skip the liner. Sigh, I wish they would sell the eyeshadows separately. I wish they would sell the eyeshadows separately... I just want to carry around the eyeshadows, but since it's an all-in-one product with the liner, the makeup pouch bulges out a bit. And if I had to nitpick, the white eyeshadow seems to wear down the fastest. Everyone's usage may vary, but since I only use this palette, the wide area I cover with the white base shade ends up getting used up quicker than the key burgundy shade. They should consider increasing the ratio of the white base portion. I recommend using your fingers rather than a brush. It's easier, faster, and more suitable for everyday use. Brushes... they probably won't work as well... 
Hwahae UserNormal SkinFeb 24, 2017The eyeliner never smudges. Since I have monolids, it usually smears, but this one dries quickly and doesn't smear at all. The only downside is that I wish there was a eyeshadow brush included. - Hwahae UserDry SkinAcne SkinAtopic SkinFeb 6, 2017
The combination of the two colors made it convenient to apply directly to my ring finger, and the eyeliner at the bottom was an added bonus. I wouldn't recommend this to those with dry skin. I have a combination of dry and oily skin, and when I used it in the winter, the powdery fallout was just way too much, so I've been heavily moisturizing the eye area while applying it. - Hwahae UserCombination SkinFeb 2, 2017
The gel eyeliner and eyeshadow come together, making it convenient to use. The eyeshadow and eyeliner colors match well. The included brush is surprisingly decent. The eyeliner tends to dry out quickly, so you need to be careful not to leave the cap open. The slightly cylindrical shape and small size make it a bit inconvenient to carry around. The almost white-looking eyeshadow color is not used often, but it's useful for absorbing excess oil before eye makeup. I'm worried it might dry out quickly, but constantly opening and closing the cap is too inconvenient, so I just flip it over, and it seems to have stayed less dried out. - Hwahae UserDry SkinDec 8, 2016
The gel eyeliner has a nice creamy consistency, making it easy to apply with the built-in brush. Moreover, it doesn't smudge as much as other eyeliners, so there's less need for touch-ups. I liked the burgundy shade, so I bought another one in brown, but there seems to be a slight difference in the products. 
Hwahae UserCombination SkinNov 12, 2016The color personally appeals to me It's a perfect burgundy for fall, not too red and not overbearing. You know, if you want to do your makeup with two eyeshadows, the two colors need to match well One is too bright and the other is too dark, so the blending doesn't work. If you add a lot of the Etude House Cafe Latte milk to this, the colors will blend well and it'll be easier to do your makeup. - ko******Combination SkinSensitive SkinSep 20, 2016
The color is beautiful and applies lightly, so it doesn't go on too thick, which I really like. Even beginners can achieve a natural-looking application. The light application is also a downside. When you're running short on time, it can be difficult to apply thickly. And the biggest problem is the excessive fallout - it's no joke. If they could improve the fallout, that would be great.
