{"content_id":"1769987","content_type":"product"}
3.87
5
20
4
3
2
1
17
Reviews
- Hwahae UserDry SkinSensitive SkinFeb 5, 2021
I snagged this at a great price during the Olive Young sale, and it's exceeded my expectations! It doesn't smudge, and the brush pen's fine tip makes for precise application. I was shocked to learn about the questionable ingredients. It applies well, but that's concerning. For a clean and pretty look, draw out the tail of the line and then smudge it gently with a cotton swab. - Hwahae UserOily SkinAcne SkinNov 2, 2020
It's easy to apply smoothly, even if you're not an expert, and it doesn't smudge much. It tends to remove in a messy way. - Hwahae UserCombination SkinAcne SkinSensitive SkinJun 2, 2020
I've repurchased this 6 times now! The color is brown, but it's closer to a deep mahogany, which gives a natural look that's neither too light nor too dark. It has a click mechanism at the end, allowing you to use every last drop even after long-term use. The best part? It doesn't smudge! I tried switching to Kiss Me brand in between, but it was so inconvenient that I came right back to this one. There's nothing disappointing about the product's performance, but the packaging design is a bit of an issue. The film on the main body peels off messily. Even though I don't carry the eyeliner around and only use it at my vanity, the film still comes off easily just from normal handling. - Hwahae UserNormal SkinJan 3, 2020
I've been struggling with eyelid oils causing even waterproof products to smudge, but this one doesn't budge at all! I've been stocking up and using it consistently for years now. Highly recommended! I'm deducting one star due to the ingredients. I didn't notice while using it, but it turns out there are 20 potentially concerning ingredients. - Hwahae UserCombination SkinSensitive SkinJul 3, 2019
I'm really satisfied with both the longevity and color of this product. It's great that it doesn't smudge even on monolids and stays put without easily rubbing off. Since it's a product where you need to shake and press to dispense the liquid, a lot of it gets stuck on the cap, which feels a bit wasteful. If you fail to control the amount, it can be quite disappointing. - Hwahae UserCombination SkinAcne SkinSensitive SkinNov 11, 2018
This product satisfies in terms of longevity, application, color, and quantity, but I had no idea it contained such problematic ingredients... :( I usually apply liquid liner to my outer corners and use a pencil for the rest. Applying liquid all over can look artificial and doesn't give me the look I want. What I love about this product is that when I tear up, instead of smudging, the formula tends to flake off bit by bit, which I find more satisfying. It's more of a clean removal rather than panda-eye smudging. The color is a deep, rich brown. It's perfect for those who don't suit black liners. It doesn't smudge easily. Being a gel formula, once it sets, it doesn't smear like a panda. If you rub your eyes or tear up, it comes off in gel flakes. I dislike overly thin liners, and this one has just the right thickness. I love that I can achieve my desired line width with just one stroke! When purchased on sale, it's reasonably priced and lasts quite a while. I stocked up on the black color earlier, and even after a year, I'm still able to use the brown shade. It seems to last forever! Caution: Contains ingredients harmful to the human body! It's so critical that I'm debating whether to continue using it. Makes me wonder if these ingredients are the reason for its long-lasting power... I was satisfied with everything else, but I'm deducting one star because of the ingredients. Try applying this product just to the outer corners of your eyes. For those with eyelids that curl upwards, applying it to the inner corners can lead to quick fading, and if you blink before it sets, it might smudge. Personally, I find using liquid liner all the way to the inner corners looks unnatural. This product is perfect for lining the outer corners. As you use it, you might notice product buildup on the sharpest part of the brush tip, which can affect application. Rinsing it once with water can dissolve the buildup, making it feel like new again! - Hwahae UserDry SkinSensitive SkinMay 19, 2018
It doesn't smudge at all. I have no double eyelids and oily eyelids, so most eyeliners smudge on me, but I've settled on this one. I used to use Kate's brush pen eyeliner, but when I was looking for a brown shade, I discovered this and switched over. Well, there's nothing particularly bad about it. If I had to pick something, maybe the price? I buy it at Olive Young using my CJ points. It has a button on the back that you press to dispense the eyeliner liquid, similar to how mechanical pencils work. One click is usually enough for one application. Be careful not to press it two or three times thinking it's not coming out, or you'll end up with way too much product. - Hwahae UserDry SkinDec 15, 2017
I've tried various types of eyeliners from brands like Tony Moly, Bobbi Brown, MAC, Innisfree, Clio, Kate, and Piaa, but they didn't work well for me. Finally, after 8 years, I found the one that works perfectly! I highly recommend this! The ink control is really difficult. I pressed it without thinking at first, and it was like an ink bomb - the ink wouldn't come off easily, and I struggled to clean it up... For ink control, you can click the cap-closed pen 1-2 times, and if the ink doesn't come out, shake it gently like a ketchup bottle 2 times, and the ink will be evenly distributed on the brush. - Hwahae UserDry SkinSensitive SkinJun 23, 2017
It applies thinly without any smudging, the color is pretty, and the price is affordable ^^ The ingredients seem to be worse than expected, and the volume seems a bit small :( - Hwahae UserCombination SkinAcne SkinSensitive SkinMay 9, 2017
I really want to praise the person who made this product. It's an unbelievable product. It doesn't smudge at all. No matter what you do, it doesn't smudge. It's waterproof, so even the most stubborn eyeliners usually smudge, but this one has never smudged for me. I've used gel liners, brush pens, and liquid liners, and they all smudge, but this product never smudges. If you're someone who struggles with smudging, you have to try this. Please, please use this. It has two types of parabens, which is surprisingly bad for the ingredients. I'll have to take off a star because of the ingredients. While it doesn't smudge easily, if you apply it incorrectly, it's hard to remove, so it can be a disaster.