{"content_id":"1824206","content_type":"product"}
3.75
5
79
4
3
2
1
223
Reviews
sh*****Dry SkinSensitive SkinBrightening/Dark SpotsInner DrynessWrinkles/ElasticityEnlarged PoresJun 1, 2025I bought this in a hurry because my previous one broke... To be honest, it's not that great. I don't think they understand what "slim" means. It's so difficult to use that I might need to buy something else. The reviewer seems disappointed with their purchase. They bought the product quickly due to necessity, but found it unsatisfactory. The main issue appears to be the product's design, particularly its "slim" feature, which makes it challenging to use. The reviewer is considering replacing it with a different product. - ye******Combination SkinSensitive SkinAcne SkinRecommendedMay 19, 2025
The skin is thin, so even clumsy hands can easily draw eyeliner. The color is also a matte brown that goes well with any makeup tone, so I highly recommend it. It's hard to gauge the degree of smudging since my eyes don't usually smudge much, but it seems to have very little smudging. Well, it's quite fragile and doesn't have much product. Is it the same as that thin Skiny Brow from Lilibyred? The thin eyebrow one is like that too. While the advantage is that it's easy to apply because it's thin, the downside is that you have to repurchase it quite often. - pe********Normal SkinBrightening/Dark SpotsWrinkles/ElasticityRecommendedFeb 27, 2025
My friend raved about it, so I tried it as soon as I got it. Even when I rubbed it with my fingers, it hardly smudged. I used to use Cl00's product, but this one seems to smudge even less. I'm thinking of buying the black one too! So far, I haven't found any. I'll need to test it on hotter days and during workouts, but I doubt I'll find any drawbacks. - a0******Dry SkinSensitive SkinAcne SkinDec 30, 2024
The color is just right - not too black, not too brown, but a perfect deep burgundy shade. I love that it's a gel eyeliner, which means it stays put once applied, giving great longevity. As someone who prioritizes ingredients, I'm thrilled that this Lilybyred gel eyeliner doesn't contain any concerning components. This was my first time using this product, and I found it challenging to apply neatly. Unlike brush pens, this gel eyeliner can be tricky to work with. If you're not careful, it can go on too thick, and achieving a clean line is quite difficult. - hs*****Combination SkinSensitive SkinAcne SkinSebum/BlackheadsDark CirclesRednessRecommendedNov 13, 2024
I've been using this for about two years now. I had trouble with other pencil liners breaking in the middle, but this product doesn't break easily and has great color payoff. It stayed put all day without smudging or fading, even when I was out and about. For me, it's a bit too intense, so I might try a different shade next time. Although it's labeled as brown, it's a very deep brown that's almost black. Occasionally it hardens and doesn't apply smoothly, but breathing on it and swatching on the back of my hand helps it glide on better. 
w4********Combination SkinBrightening/Dark SpotsSebum/BlackheadsDark CirclesEnlarged PoresRecommendedSep 28, 2024Although the tip is a bit blunt, it draws a sharp line when you extend it with your nail. It's incredibly easy for beginners to use. It smudges easily and wears down quickly. When it gets too blunt, it becomes difficult to draw precise lines. - du********Oily SkinAcne SkinRednessRecommendedSep 1, 2024
The color looks natural and it's easy to apply, which I love. Plus, the staying power is pretty decent. Downsides? Not really any. Maybe just that it breaks easily? But that's not a big issue if you're careful with it. - wk********Combination SkinDead Skin CellsRecommendedAug 18, 2024
I was worried the pencil type might smudge, but I'm pleasantly surprised by its incredible staying power. It lasts much longer than expected! It's a bit stiff, so you need to apply it over foundation. If you put it on after powder, it doesn't glide on as smoothly. - si******Combination SkinSensitive SkinAcne SkinBrightening/Dark SpotsSebum/BlackheadsDark CirclesRecommendedAug 17, 2024
A natural dark brown shade that's not as intense as black. It has great staying power, and the thin tip makes it easy to apply. I really love it! If you have dry skin around your eyes, it might not glide on as smoothly as you'd expect. If you're looking for a dark brown shade, go for No. 2 Matte Brown rather than No. 3 Walnut Brown. - jo*******Dehydrated SkinAcne SkinBrightening/Dark SpotsSebum/BlackheadsDark CirclesInner DrynessWrinkles/ElasticityEnlarged PoresDead Skin CellsRecommendedAug 6, 2024
Great staying power and intense color. It's an eyeliner you can use without any worries. The application isn't as smooth and gliding as Clio's. It's a bit stiff when applying.
