ProsI'm writing this review to remember my experience!!
Overall: It's a strange product that smudges easily, but when used with a no-sebum powder, it becomes so difficult to remove that cleansing becomes a challenge. I won't be repurchasing...
✓ The absorbs well is good. I saw reviews saying it doesn't apply smoothly, but I didn't experience that at all.
✓ I like how thin it is. While it's not extremely fine, it's thin enough. If you want to draw a thicker line, you'll need to apply multiple layers, which might feel wasteful!
✓ When used with a no-sebum powder, it doesn't smudge. It stays put to the point where it's hard to remove.
Cons✗ It smudges easily... I didn't notice at first, but maybe because I have oily skin, I sometimes end up with brown smudges under my eyes if I'm not careful.
✗ It's inconvenient that you can't retract the eyeliner. I prefer to pull out as much as I need, apply it quickly, and then put it back, so this wasn't ideal for me.
✗ It breaks easily. I think it broke even when I only extended it about 2mm. Because of this, I had to use it by extending just a tiny bit each time.
TipPro tip: Always use it with a no-sebum powder!! This prevents smudging and keeps it from coming off. In fact, it sets so well that it can be challenging to remove during cleansing.