While using Etude House palettes, this one was personally the most... well, disappointing. I usually trust and use Etude House shadow palettes, whether they're 10-pan, 4-pan, or 9-pan, but this Wine Party palette left me feeling a bit let down. That being said, the color combination really appeals to me - it reminds me of deep red wine, perfect for creating a moody eye look. I found myself reaching for it often during autumn and winter. Out of the 10 shades, the 5 on the left are ideal for a brown daily eye look, while the 5 on the right have more reddish tones, great for creating a sophisticated wine-colored eye when applied with a light hand. The first shade, a bright ivory white matte shadow, works well for brightening the entire eyelid and under-eye area. It's also good for absorbing oil on the eyelids, serving as a powder substitute.
The main disappointment lies in the two glittery shades with fine shimmer. Their pigmentation is incredibly weak. Even after multiple applications, the color payoff is so subtle it's barely noticeable. This aspect was quite frustrating. Of course, for those who prefer very light makeup, this might actually be a plus. The light brown matte shadow also has weak pigmentation, requiring several layers for a subtle, soft effect, which was a bit disappointing. While the deeper, more intense colors have better pigmentation, the dark purple-tinted shade at the end can be tricky to blend when applied lightly, so it's best to use a very small amount and build up gradually. There's a slight issue with excess powder, but this is common with many eyeshadow palettes, so it doesn't particularly bother me.
To improve the pigmentation of the weaker shades, try applying a small amount of eye primer before layering on the color. This should help with both color payoff and longevity.