{"content_id":"1944998","content_type":"product"}
3.46
5
269
4
3
2
1
102
Reviews
- Hwahae UserOily SkinSensitive SkinJun 6, 2024
The color payoff is great and it's resistant to the natural oils around the eyes, so it doesn't smudge. The unique packaging makes it a bit inconvenient to store and organize. - Hwahae UserOily SkinAcne SkinJan 23, 2024
I usually use brush pen liners, but they seemed to run out too quickly, so I opted for this gel liner with a larger quantity. First off, the pigmentation is excellent. Even among black liners, some brush pens can be a bit watery, but this product has a rich, deep black color that I love. Initially, I was worried that being a gel liner, it might dry out fast, but I've been using it for over a year now and it's still smooth and hasn't dried up at all. It's also convenient to use - I just put a small amount on the cap, which makes it easy to control how much product I apply with the brush. There's not really anything disappointing about the product's performance. The only issue is that while it's an all-in-one with the brush, I've noticed the brush keeps coming loose from the case with use. - Hwahae UserNormal SkinMay 2, 2022
The color payoff is on point. Staying power is impressive. It's easy to apply. After trying other products, I always end up coming back to this one. Can't argue with that, right? Any downsides? Not really. I guess you could say you might get bored of it after a while? Anyway, I try other products thinking there might be something better out there, but I always end up using this one again. It's a full circle! As long as you take good care of the brush, you're golden. - Hwahae UserCombination SkinOct 14, 2020
This review is based on using an entire container of the product. * Ingredients While it's hard to say the ingredients are great due to small amounts of parabens and BHT, I didn't experience any eye irritation when using it. I hope Tony Moly will remove these ingredients in future renewals. * Color Payoff It applies as a deep black color with good pigmentation. The black shade was useful for creating defined eye looks. * Application As a gel eyeliner, it glides on smoothly. It was convenient not only for filling in lines but also for creating winged looks. * Staying Power There was minimal smudging on my eyes. Especially when I dusted powder on my eyelids and under-eye area right after application, it reduced smudging even further. * Volume and Price The product volume is substantial, and it comes with a built-in brush, allowing for long-term use. When purchased during Tony Moly sales, it offers better value for money compared to other pencil eyeliners. - Due to the nature of gel eyeliners, if you don't clean the brush after use, it hardens, which was quite bothersome to clean frequently. - It's disappointing that the ingredients include parabens and BHT. - Hwahae UserCombination SkinAcne SkinSensitive SkinAug 26, 2020
I bought this for makeup practice, and it definitely lived up to expectations. It applies smoothly and the color payoff is excellent. The downside is that it smudges easily, and the brush part tends to dry out quickly. If you're planning to use it, I'd recommend removing any excess oil from your skin and taking steps to prevent smudging for the best results! - Hwahae UserCombination SkinAtopy SkinAcne SkinJun 15, 2020
The color payoff is fantastic! You can precisely draw the shape you want. It's a bit challenging to apply. You need to practice diligently to get the hang of it and achieve a decent result. - Hwahae UserOily SkinAcne SkinApr 30, 2020
First off, the color payoff is fantastic! The pigmentation is absolutely amazing. The brush is incredibly soft, making it a joy to use. As for staying power, it's phenomenal. I wore it for about 5 hours and there was no smudging at all - the longevity is seriously impressive. The only downside is that it's quite challenging to correct mistakes when drawing the eyeliner. This aspect gets three stars from me. When I tried to fix my eyeliner without a cotton swab, using just water, it smudged quite badly. When I first started using this product, it was a bit tricky to apply. However, with continued use, I found it became much easier and more comfortable to work with. - Hwahae UserDry SkinAcne SkinSensitive SkinMar 23, 2020
This is my holy grail eyeliner! I've tried to switch to others, but nothing draws as well as this one! The color payoff is incredible! It's also super easy to apply, making it great even for beginners. If I had to point out a downside, it would be cleaning the brush. After using the eyeliner, the brush tends to harden and become stiff. Make sure to clean the brush thoroughly! - Hwahae UserCombination SkinAcne SkinSensitive SkinFeb 8, 2020
Personally, I think it's easy for beginners to use. The brush is built-in, so there's no need to buy one separately. The color payoff is great, and it lived up to my expectations. The price is reasonable too, making it worth trying. The biggest disappointment is that it smudges... I applied it during first period at school, and by fourth period, probably because I'd been smiling all day, there were eyeliner marks in my aegyo sal area. Even after wiping it off, it kept smudging. I eventually removed it and switched to a brush pen, which didn't have this issue. Also, while the product volume is generous, it dries out quickly, so I doubt I'll be able to use it all. The brush needs constant cleaning, which is a bit inconvenient. If it weren't for the smudging, I would have continued using it. Maybe it's because I have oily skin and high body temperature. To prevent it from drying out, you can store the container upside down. When applying, put some gel on the brush, then warm it up a bit on the back of your hand or with your breath to make it more pliable. This will help you achieve a smoother and more defined line. Always clean the brush after use for easier application next time. - Hwahae UserCombination SkinAcne SkinNov 9, 2019
The color payoff is excellent. It's the best gel liner I've tried. This creates an overly artificial-looking eyeliner. Also, the brush and gel dry out too quickly.