{"content_id":"1992578","content_type":"product"}
4.53
20
5
4
3
2
1
13
Reviews
- Hwahae UserCombination SkinMar 11, 2025
• Honest review from my own purchase • Applies smoothly without any discomfort • After failing several job interviews, I went to a makeup studio and they used this • It's a sophisticated black-brown shade • Made in Germany • Creates a beautiful makeup look • There's absolutely nothing to complain about, I just wish it came with a refill • At the makeup studio, they told me that since I don't have double eyelids, it tends to smudge easily. So they applied fixer with a cotton swab, then drew the liner, and applied fixer again. It stayed beautiful all day long! - Hwahae UserCombination SkinAcne SkinSensitive SkinMar 10, 2025
* Color: If you find deep black too intense, I recommend the Clio Extreme Black Brown eyeliner. I've settled on this one myself. * Application: It's so smooth! Draw your line and quickly smudge it with your fingernail before it dries for a beautiful effect. * Even as someone with monolids, I find it easy to apply. You can snag it at a great price when it's on sale on Hwahae! It's fine when you first open it, but around halfway through... it keeps breaking. That was really frustrating! - Hwahae UserDry SkinAcne SkinDec 2, 2024
I've always used Clio's thin gel pencil liner, but I switched to this one and I love how smoothly it applies. The tip is quite thick, so you'll need to use a different eyeliner for creating a fine wing. - Hwahae UserDry SkinSensitive SkinFeb 26, 2024
30s / Summer Cool Light / Dry Sensitive Skin I've only been using Clio or Cosme products, and I've been sticking to thin liner products from the same brand. I was curious about this product, so I decided to give it a try. The color is black-brown, which seemed like it would work well for me, and I bought it after reading reviews that said it doesn't smudge. It applies smoothly, and even when I check after work, it hasn't smudged at all since I put it on in the morning. This product definitely smudges less than what I was using before. However, since I'm used to applying very thin lines, I find it a bit challenging to work with as it goes on thicker. Still, the fact that it doesn't smudge is its biggest advantage. The color appears a bit darker and more vivid than other dark brown shades I've seen. Overall, I'm satisfied with it and continue to use it. Because it's not as thin as I'm used to, it tends to create thicker lines when applying. This can be a bit inconvenient. - Hwahae UserNormal SkinSensitive SkinFeb 2, 2024
This is my absolute favorite eyeliner. The black-brown color is so beautiful and suits cool skin tones perfectly. I love how smoothly it applies - it's not too soft, yet not too firm. It never smudges, which is fantastic. Clio really knows how to make great products. The only downside is that it feels like there's not enough product in the pen. It runs out quite quickly. - Hwahae UserOily SkinSensitive SkinJan 6, 2024
It glides on smoothly with minimal smudging. The color stayed put until the afternoon. No complaints so far. I wish it came in a larger size. I'm enjoying using it, so I don't have any issues at the moment. - Hwahae UserDry SkinAcne SkinSensitive SkinJun 5, 2023
Skin type: 19-20 summer cool tone, dry (dehydrated) The pencil liner's formula glides on smoothly, making it easy to fill in the waterline! While it applies smoothly, I personally found it smudged quite a bit! - Hwahae UserCombination SkinSensitive SkinMay 6, 2023
It absorbs smoothly, and the color is sophisticated and calming. I've already purchased this multiple times. If you apply the eyeshadow skillfully, it doesn't smudge easily, allowing for a natural makeup look. There's nothing particularly disappointing about it. As you use it, the tip becomes blunt, which makes it a bit challenging to apply to the outer corners of the eyes. It's perfect for creating a smoky eye look. - Hwahae UserOily SkinAtopy SkinAcne SkinSensitive SkinMay 4, 2023
The color is so natural and beautiful. It applies smoothly, making it very comfortable to use, and the staying power is great too! Since there's no sharpener and it's quite thick, it's difficult to create a thin, subtle look. - Hwahae UserDehydrated SkinAcne SkinNov 30, 2022
I bought this after watching Risabae's video. It applies smoothly and the color looks natural. The tip is quite blunt, so after drawing the eyeliner, you need to clean up the tail end with your fingernail or a pointed cotton swab.