{"content_id":"1992582","content_type":"product"}
4.60
35
5
4
3
2
1
12
Reviews
- Hwahae UserDehydrated SkinAcne SkinMay 23, 2025
I used to love the previous version before it was discontinued. After it disappeared, I tried other Clio pencils, but they smudged too much on my eyes, so I stopped using them. Then, while browsing Olive Young, I stumbled upon this product and decided to give it a try... and I'm so happy I did! It's great, except for one small issue. The pencil tip gets blunt quickly, which is a bit disappointing for someone like me who prefers a fine line. However, the color payoff is excellent, it's easy to fill in the waterline, and it's perfect for everyday use. Most importantly, it doesn't smudge much at all. For me, the most crucial aspect of an eyeliner is its ability to stay put, and this one really delivers. Of course, on days when I didn't control oil well and laughed a lot, it smudged a bit, but I consider that my fault! On important days, I apply a tiny bit of fixer with a cotton swab over the liner, and it truly doesn't budge. For daily wear, I just make sure to control oil with eyeshadow, apply the liner, and set the outer corners with more shadow. With this routine, it lasts at least 6 hours without any touch-ups, smudging, or fading. It's challenging to create a fine line as the tip gets blunt quickly. Occasionally, it can smudge if you don't control oil properly. Applying eyeshadow or a fixer over the liner seems to extend its longevity even further. - Hwahae UserDehydrated SkinSensitive SkinFeb 2, 2025
The packaging is sleek and smooth, and it's thicker than other eyeliners, making it comfortable to hold. It's way too thick! There's no sharpener included, and it doesn't fit any of my existing ones. The line it draws is incredibly blunt, which is really disappointing. I can't understand why they made the eyeliner so thick - they should have at least included a sharpener. To make matters worse, it doesn't even have good staying power. - Hwahae UserOily SkinAcne SkinSep 11, 2024
For someone like me who smiles so big my eyes disappear, the most crucial feature of an eyeliner is that it doesn't smudge!!!! This product absolutely delivers on that front. Among the pencil liners I've tried, this one seems to have the best staying power and smudge resistance. There was a time when I dreaded doing eye makeup because everything would smear, but since switching to this, I rarely have that problem! Let's be honest, as long as an eyeliner doesn't smudge, that's all that really matters, right? The color is beautiful too! My eyes are naturally light brown, and this complements my eye color perfectly. Like all pencil eyeliners, it's quite blunt when you first start using it. If you're transitioning from liquid liners, you might find it really challenging to apply at first. (Oh, how I wish for a super sharp pencil liner!) However, once you get used to it, it becomes incredibly easy and convenient to apply with just a few quick strokes. When I want a more natural eye look, or on days when I don't feel like using liquid liner, this is my go-to product! - Hwahae UserDehydrated SkinSensitive SkinSep 10, 2024
Highly recommended for filling in the lip lines. It applies smoothly and evenly. The texture feels a bit too soft, and the shape is quite blunt, making it easy for the product to smear outside the lip line. - Hwahae UserCombination SkinFeb 20, 2024
It feels soft and seems to last quite a while. The color is versatile, so I find myself using it without much hesitation. The tip is blunt and too soft, making it difficult to create a sharp wing. I use a different liner for the wing and this product for the main eye line. - Hwahae UserDry SkinSensitive SkinNov 22, 2023
The soft texture made it easy to apply, and I loved the dark, subdued color. While it's slightly thick, you get the hang of it with practice and can draw a nice line. Due to its softness, it can easily become blunt. If you prefer drawing thin eyeliner, I'd recommend the Sharp So Simple liner instead. - Hwahae UserDehydrated SkinAcne SkinSep 25, 2023
The color is beautiful and it's easy to apply! The staying power was also pretty decent. The tip was too blunt... It was a bit tricky to create a sharp wing, and it broke easily. - Hwahae UserDry SkinAcne SkinSensitive SkinMar 12, 2023
It absorbs beautifully and smoothly. The application is top-notch! It's great for beginners to practice with, and it's easy to remove and correct right after applying. The staying power isn't bad either. I wish it was just a bit thinner. It's so soft that it tends to get blunt easily. It applies a bit thick, so you need to draw carefully. - Hwahae UserDehydrated SkinAcne SkinSensitive SkinJan 27, 2023
I loved the color - it's right in between black and brown, creating a look that's neither too sharp nor too soft! I was worried because many reviews said it wasn't smooth, but it actually applies very smoothly. If you set it well, the staying power is quite good, so I'm satisfied! The lead is thick and blunt, making it difficult to draw a sharp tail on the brows! - Hwahae UserCombination SkinSep 26, 2022
Before I tried this, I was using a pencil liner that was too hard. It didn't apply well, and forcing it on irritated the skin around my eyes. I ended up switching to liquid liners because of that. But this? It's a whole new world! It's so soft and applies smoothly without smudging... It's amazing! I bought it because I heard the color works well for light undertones, and it's true - the color is absolutely beautiful! Everyone mentioned that the thickness was a drawback, and they're right. When it's new and sharp, it applies perfectly. But once that part wears down and it becomes blunt, that's when it gets a bit tricky... I don't have time to sharpen it in the morning when I'm in a rush. If they release a thinner version, I'll buy it in a heartbeat!