Name: am9 to pm9 SURVIVAL PENLINER NATURAL [02 #Ash Brown]
Brand: lilybyred
Rating: 4.52 (69 reviews)

Rich and earthy shades like mustard yellow, olive green, and chocolate brown look great on you

How to Write a TikTok Review
 Help us keep the Hwahae community trustworthy by following these guidelines: 
Reviews that violate these may be removed without notice.

Bright and fresh shades like coral, warm pinks, and fresh greens look great on you

Soft and muted shades like pastel blues, dusty pinks, and soft lavenders look great on you

High-contrast and bold shades like pure white, black, icy blues, and deep reds look great on you

I confirm this is my own TikTok video and agree it maybe featured on Hwahae.
 Any misuse may result in removal or restrictions.
 For details, tap the

Our service will be temporarily unavailable during:

Scheduled Maintenance

Each product allows one tiktok video review and one text review

This is a Health Functional Food certified by the Ministry of Food and Drug Safety (MFDS) of Korea, designed to help maintain and improve your health.

This review was written by The Hwahae Testers who received the product for free and evaluated it with a sense of representing Hwahae. The review is completely unbiased and honest, with no guidelines or restrictions.

Reviews by The Hwahae Testers undergo the same strict verification process as regular reviews, and if they don't meet our standards, revisions will be requested.

Each ingredient is selected for its specific purpose, such as improving skin hydration or brightening. However, the inclusion of these ingredients does not guarantee the overall effectiveness of the final product. Simply using these ingredients does not ensure the product will deliver the claimed benefits.

AI-Analyzed Reviews are coming soon!
We're gathering more reviews to provide you with the best insights.

Be the first to share your experience!
Used this product?
Share your TikTok review to help others discover it.

The content is currently being reviewed by the Hwahae operations team, and the verification will be completed by the next business day (excluding weekends and holidays) from the date the review was written.

Help us keep the Hwahae community trustworthy by following these guidelines.
Reviews that don’t follow the standards may be removed without notice.

Reviews that don’t follow the guidelines may be removed without prior notice.

Tell us about what you liked - texture, results, skin type, etc

Tell us what didn’t work - texture, skin reaction, or why you wouldn’t recommend it

릴리바이레드

am9 to pm9 SURVIVAL PENLINER NATURAL [02 #Ash Brown]

Not Vivid

Bold

Not Olive-Toned

Smudges

Absorbs Well

Clumps

Causes Itching

Soft

Looks Natural

Long-Lasting

Brown-Toned

Easy to Draw

Good Pigmentation

Not Heavy

The only downside was how quickly it faded.
It took about 10 applications before it started to show up, even then it was quite faint.

If you're into that "no-makeup makeup" look, this is a must-try!
When you swatch it on the back of your hand, it might seem a bit dark, but on your face, it's actually more subtle and natural-looking.
I often use it for a light wash of color or to accentuate my aegyo-sal (under-eye area), and it works perfectly. It's not just water-resistant - the staying power is impressive, lasting at least half a day!
As a warm-toned person, I found the brown shade quite flattering. I also bought the ash black, and there's not a huge difference between the two, so I switch between them.
If you have a darker complexion, the brown might be too subtle, so I'd recommend the ash black!

나인투나인 서바이벌 펜라이너 내추럴 [02 #애쉬브라운]

If you're concerned, try applying an eye primer first, then the product, and finish with a light dusting of powder.

Well, I find it a bit disappointing that I'm required to write at least 20 characters about what I dislike.

Even though I sweat a lot and have oily eyelids, plus frequent tearing due to dry eyes, this product holds up well. It lasts from when I arrive at work until I leave, without needing any touch-ups.

This eyeliner offers versatility and a natural finish, perfect for those who want a softer look. The buildable formula allows for customization, from subtle to more defined lines. The value for money with the buy-one-get-one offer is an added bonus. While there's a slight weight to the product, it's barely noticeable during wear.

No real downsides to mention
It feels slightly heavier, but not enough to be bothersome

For those who find bold eyeliners too overpowering on their face,
This one's great for a more natural look
After a color analysis showed high contrast didn't suit me, I tried the natural shade and I'm loving it
You can adjust the intensity by layering - one stroke for subtle, multiple for bolder
The 1+1 deal makes it budget-friendly too

Be careful when choosing! Check if the word "natural" is on the label or not!

The color is a letdown! I was using matte black before and wanted something that screamed "eyeliner!" I intended to buy brown but didn't realize this was "natural" and hastily purchased it based on the brown label. My mistake, I suppose... I was expecting a matte brown, so this doesn't suit me. This ash brown is... well, it's less ashy and more like a watered-down shade? The swatch in the photo is pretty accurate to real life. As a result, it's much lighter than using eyeshadow or gel liner for a more intense look. It fades over time, appearing as if it's been wiped off. No matter how many times I apply it or how much pressure I use, I can't get rid of that washed-out color.

The brush's application is great! It doesn't split and seems to work well.

If you make a mistake, don't worry too much. Gently scratch it off with your fingernail, and it'll come right off. Rubbing doesn't work as well, but scratching is the most effective method.

Honestly, I can't think of any downsides, except for my own shaky hands when applying it.

As a complete eyeliner novice, I wanted to start with something subtle for practice, which is why I chose this one. Let me tell you, it's water-resistant and doesn't budge easily - that's how long-lasting it is! To be honest, there's a tiny bit of smudging if you really rub it, but it doesn't spread all over the place, which is great. The best part is the light color, making it perfect for underlining and absolute beginners like me. I even drew it a bit awkwardly once, but people hardly noticed any mistakes. It's truly a godsend for newbies! I have a warm complexion, and shade 02 worked well for me. If you want a darker look, go for 01, and for an even lighter touch, I'd recommend 03.

You can build up the intensity by applying multiple layers.

If you're not looking for a vibrant color, this shade is just perfect.

It has a subtle and natural look.
It lasts longer than expected and doesn't easily come off.
Just keep in mind, it's not black, so it gives a more natural appearance rather than a bold look.
Something to consider!

I may be applying it incorrectly, but the ink seems to clump together a bit. Especially when I draw it too thinly the first time, and then have to go over it again, there are often cases where the ink clumps up right away, although that's not always the case. So when I want to go over it again, it's safer to wait until it's just slightly dried before drawing.

Other eyeliners usually only come in black or brown, and even though they call the brown 'natural', when you actually use it, it ends up being too dark and making your eyes look stuffy. So I would sometimes not even draw an eyeliner line at all. But this product, while the color is light, it's not too light, so the line looks subtly visible without making my eyes look stuffy at all - it's just perfect.

The staying power isn't particularly long-lasting. However, the color is beautiful! It's portable enough to reapply throughout the day. It's not an overly intense or overwhelming style!

As someone with cool undertones who doesn't suit heavy eyeliner, this product is amazing! The upper part is ash brown, creating a natural look that doesn't make my eyes appear heavy. It's my first time using a brush pen, and it's so easy! Perfect for a no-makeup makeup look. It's like I'm not wearing anything, yet my eyes look defined and bright!

The product is so good that I can't think of any downsides!

Highly recommended for those seeking a natural makeup look! The color is so beautiful without being artificial... The staying power is excellent, it doesn't break down. I accidentally rubbed my eyes and this was the only product that didn't budge, haha!

I'll have to use it more to know for sure, but I don't see any particular drawbacks. I like it!

Lilybyred Nine-to-Nine Survival Pen Liner Natural [02 Ash Brown] 1g

Expiration date: 2028.2.24
The long shelf life makes it a great item to stock up on!

The nude pink? packaging is so pretty!
It absorbs well and is easy to apply.
The ash brown color seems like it would naturally suit anyone.
The staying power is great - I applied it at lunch and it was still perfect at night.
It's also great for drawing precise, detailed eyeliner.

For best results, try applying Ash Taupe below the eyes and Ash Black above the eyes

If you keep applying layers before it dries completely, you might experience some clumping

I've been avoiding heavy eyeliners that make my eyes look cramped, but this one has such a natural color payoff that it creates an open, fresh-looking makeup look without feeling overwhelming. I love it!

Korean Reviews

am9 to pm9 SURVIVAL PENLINER NATURAL [02 #Ash Brown]

2 Reviews