{"content_id":"2018935","content_type":"product"}
Hwahae
제품 이미지
lilybyred
lilybyred

9 to 9 Survival Penliner Natural [03 Ash Taupe]

4.5018
Retail Price₩12,000
Size1g
Ranking

TikTok Reviews

AI-Analyzed Reviews

Pros
  • Lasts Long8
  • Soft5
  • Brown-Toned4
  • Looks Natural4
  • Recommended for Fall Warm Tones2
  • Recommended for Warm Tones2
  • Has a Shading Effect2
Cons
  • Not Olive-Toned2
  • Pills on Skin1
  • Poor Pigmentation1
  • Smudges1
  • Clumps1
  • Smudges Easily1

18

Reviews

4.50

11
5
4
3
2
1

Korean Reviews

  • zn******** profile image
    zn********
    Oily SkinSensitive SkinAcne SkinBrightening/Dark SpotsSebum/Blackheads
    RecommendedMay 16, 2025
    Wow, the Hwahae eyeliner. I've never even used a black eyeliner in my life, being a summer mute whose eye makeup doesn't suit me, but this is the only one I can use. What's with the oily lids, the double eyelid, and eyeliner, you know? But when the eyeliner is too pigmented, it looks really weird, so I tried a lighter one, and wow, the longevity is insane. I've never seen oilier skin than mine, but this is the only eyeliner that truly survives on my eyes. It's really the best.
    If the bold eyeliner doesn't suit you, just buy it.
    Although you can draw eyeliner using an eyebrow pencil, when you want a more defined look, you would use it.

  • dl*******
    Combination SkinSensitive SkinBrightening/Dark SpotsSebum/BlackheadsInner DrynessWrinkles/ElasticityEnlarged Pores
    May 7, 2025
    The bottom one is Ash Taupe. It gives a subtle, natural look. I bought it to add some shadow underneath, but it's so sheer that when I try to build it up, it starts looking odd!
    I think Ash Brown might be better. This shade has a yellowish tint, and it's barely noticeable on the skin.

Ingredients

What's inside

All Ingredients19
1-2Low-Risk13
3-6Medium-Risk5
7-10High-Risk1
Undetermined0

All Ingredients

19
20 Ingredients to Avoid
6
Potential Allergen
0

Ingredient Functions

4
Moisturizing
1
Skin Barrier Protection
0
Lock in hydration
0
Soothing
0
Exfoliating
0
Brightening
0
Acne Care
0
Sun Protection
0
Anti-Wrinkle

Ingredient Information:

Each ingredient is selected for its specific purpose, such as improving skin hydration or brightening. However, the inclusion of these ingredients does not guarantee the overall effectiveness of the final product. Simply using these ingredients does not ensure the product will deliver the claimed benefits.


Ingredients by Skin Type

Oily Skin
0
0
Dry Skin
2
0
Sensitive Skin
0
0
  • We recommend reviewing the full ingredient list from the manufacturer/brand before purchasing.
  • Unauthorized use of Hwahae’s content for commercial purposes may result in legal action.
  • The ingredient ratios are provided by the brand, which is fully responsible for their accuracy.

Do you have any children under the age of 6?

We can help guide you to baby-related products