{"content_id":"1824208","content_type":"product"}
4.19
8
5
4
3
2
1
16
Reviews
- su*******Dry SkinRecommendedApr 13, 2025
The brown color creates a natural-looking eye contour. The shade of brown is neither too dark nor too light, giving a soft appearance. The thin eyeliner allows for precise application, defining the eyes beautifully. It's long-lasting and doesn't smudge easily. The product quality is exceptional, especially considering its very reasonable price. Due to the thin design, it feels like there's less eyeliner product. I wish they had included more product... - ab******Combination SkinSensitive SkinBrightening/Dark SpotsSebum/BlackheadsDark CirclesEnlarged PoresJul 8, 2024
The color is beautiful and it lasts a long time. The subtle shimmer gives a pure and innocent look when applied. It breaks easily, unfortunately. The application feels a bit stiff and doesn't absorb as smoothly as I'd like. - gk*****Combination SkinSensitive SkinSebum/BlackheadsEnlarged PoresRecommendedMay 12, 2024
This is an incredibly thin pencil eyeliner. I bought it after seeing the product name 'Nine to Nine', and I was surprised by how well it stays put without smudging, which is better than I expected. My eye area tends to make liners and mascaras smudge a lot, but this product has the least smudging and longest-lasting effect of any I've tried. I wanted to buy a brown shade, but it was sold out in-store, so I went with 'Glam Mocha' which is close to brown. It has a slight shimmer that gives a bright yet soft color. The shimmer isn't overwhelming at all. While it is slim, the tip becomes blunt with continued use. You'll need to sharpen the liner tip to keep it pointed before applying. - yo*******Dry SkinSensitive SkinBrightening/Dark SpotsEnlarged PoresRecommendedJan 23, 2024
Unbeatable when it comes to smudge-proof and smooth application... Grab all the Lilybyred Natu-Nara you can! There's not really anything bad, but the color is a bit light for eyeliner use! Go for black or brown shades instead. For perfection, use a brush pen for the tail and fill in the inner eye area and waterline with this - it's easily removable there. - qh********Dry SkinSensitive SkinAtopic SkinRecommendedJan 6, 2022
✓ Long-lasting wear. I've tried all the famous eyeliners out there, but as an eyeliner nomad, I've finally settled on Lilybyred! It's so good that I've used nearly 10 and stocked up on 6 more! ✓ Great ingredients. I have atopic dermatitis around my eyes, so ingredients are crucial. This product seems trustworthy! ✓ Thin tip. The thin tip makes it easy to draw a wing without any hassle. It's really fantastic! ✗ Color is too dark. I usually use Caramel Brown, but it was sold out, so I tried this. As someone with a light complexion and deep undertones, it was a bit dark for me. I'll probably go back to Caramel Brown. ✗ Product doesn't come out even when there's still some left. This seems to be an issue with all pencil eyeliners, unfortunately. ✗ Not readily available. I originally bought it on Coupang, but it sold out quickly. When I went to Olive Young, it wasn't there either. I asked about restocking, but they said there were no plans to reproduce it. I was so disappointed! Please don't stop producing Lilybyred! ✗ Small amount of product. Maybe because it's thin, but the amount seems really small. It would be great if they could make the pencil longer. - jj*******Combination SkinSensitive SkinRecommendedFeb 26, 2021
I've tried all varieties of Lilybyred Starry Eyes Eyeliner. The Glam Mocha shade has a subtle shimmer. It's great for creating a natural-looking line. The color payoff and longevity seem a bit lacking. Sometimes I find it's worn off after a while. - db*******Dry SkinSensitive SkinAtopic SkinDark CirclesInner DrynessRednessRecommendedJan 23, 2021
Natural coffee color that's not too intense. Doesn't smudge easily. Has a subtle shimmer that looks beautifully natural. Thin enough to be perfect for filling in the outer corners of eyes and waterline. The amount feels a bit small for the price. The lead seems a bit soft, making it prone to breaking. - ch******Normal SkinBrightening/Dark SpotsRecommendedDec 30, 2020
It glides on smoothly and I love how thin it is. The staying power is great too. I had to buy a new one because it dried out. You need to take good care of it to prevent it from hardening. - wm******Combination SkinAcne SkinAtopic SkinRecommendedAug 23, 2020
The staying power is decent and it's slim, making it easy to apply! The color is also quite nice! In my opinion, the color is a bit lighter than I expected and the shimmer is more noticeable! - rl*********Combination SkinAcne SkinRecommendedAug 21, 2020
The color is beautiful and natural, making it a pleasure to use! I really like it. It breaks easily if you're not careful when putting it back. I think it's already broken twice...