{"content_id":"1809533","content_type":"product"}
4.56
11
5
4
3
2
1
18
Reviews
- 6v********Dry SkinRecommendedJul 8, 2024
I've tried various products, but this one's the best for me. It doesn't smudge due to oil when I smile or as time passes. I'm leaving a review because I love it so much. I bought two at once, and I'm almost out, so I'm planning to buy more! The price is a bit steep, but it lasts a long time and the performance is definitely worth it. - ho*********Dry SkinRecommendedApr 19, 2023
I've been using this product for years now. The pen-like shape makes it easy to draw a pretty line, and I love how quickly it dries. With daily use, it lasts about 4-5 months. After 4 months, the color starts to fade a bit. While it doesn't smudge much, if I apply it in the morning, it does wear off a little by evening. The brown shade looks more natural than black, so I usually use this color. When I want my makeup to look more intense and long-lasting, I layer the black on top for a beautiful yet natural look. - po*****Dry SkinWrinkles/ElasticityEnlarged PoresRecommendedOct 26, 2020
The staying power is great! I prefer a thicker line to emphasize my eyes, and this eyeliner does exactly that! The price is steep and it can be hard to find. Other than that, I can't think of any real downsides... 
se*****Combination SkinRecommendedOct 7, 2020Compared to other products, this one is more intense and defined, making it a beloved item. Highly recommended! I wish they would release a version with a softer brush tip. The current one is too stiff... 
Hwahae UserDry SkinAtopic SkinSep 9, 2020I loved that it didn't smudge. The color payoff was great, and I often received compliments on how pretty the eyeliner shade looked. First off, the ingredients aren't the best. If you have super sensitive skin, you might want to avoid this. The applicator brush feels a bit rough. There's also some clumping. - Hwahae UserDry SkinSensitive SkinRecommendedFeb 7, 2020
Draws naturally and beautifully. I'm really bad at eyeliner and always mess it up, but this is easy to apply. The dark brown color is spot-on. The price is reasonable too. It doesn't smudge and glides on smoothly. I'll definitely repurchase. This... comes off really easily with water. However, it doesn't smudge excessively. 
Hwahae UserCombination SkinSensitive SkinAcne SkinRecommendedJun 14, 2019# With the triple combo of pore-filling primer, eye primer, and tears welling up from the pain of smudging eyeliner, I have the saddest eyes that no matter how prettily I line the corners, it all wipes off in a few hours due to sebum. š¢ Anyone can see that this eyeliner is made to be easily removed... for eyes like mine, this eyeliner is a godsendā” I don't even use eyeliner daily, but I have over 5 of these in use. # I can never use pencil liners no matter how much they claim to be smudge-proof - they still smear and make my eyes look bruised all around. But this one doesn't do that!! The wing I draw in the morning stays put until I get home ~ All the liquid liners I tried from Clio/Kate/Kiss Me that claimed to be non-smudging were useless, but this one really doesn't budge. It's amazing... That's why I always recommend this to people looking for a non-smudging liner, and they're all satisfied except for the price.. # Since my hair and eyes are both brown, I only use brown shades. Black looks too harsh and intense for me š¢ # It's expensive š¢ But I sometimes get the 1+1 deal to get it at a better price! # The brush gets stained easily š¢ I can wipe it clean with a tissue and it works fine again, but it feels thin and delicate š¢.š¢ # I love glitter eyeshadows, so when I layer that with the liner, the brush gets really stained š¢š¢ But the liner and eyeshadow combo still looks natural and pretty~ And these days with the summer heat, the pore-filling primer is a must-have ^^ 
le**********Dry SkinRecommendedJun 5, 2019I bought the Kitten Karma and Rose Gold Retro at the same time, and the products that Stila had given me as a gift... but I feel like I was completely taken advantage of. Of course, the application is good and the lasting power is good, but if you prioritize these, there is the Kiss Me eyeliner, so you can set that aside. The color of this one is just stunning. The color is really, really beautiful - a gorgeous deep brown. The best part is that even when you apply it quite heavily, it doesn't look overdone and the eye makeup looks subtly deep. Kiss Me is also a dark brown, and Stila is also a dark brown, but Stila leans more reddish-brown and has a lighter color payoff. Personally, I'm in love with the Aiden Dingso Soft Matte Brown pencil liner, and they complement each other perfectly, so I plan to keep repurchasing this. The eyeshadow brush that came as a gift when I bought the 2 metallic glitters is also working really well for me. The bristles are soft, and it's a better quality brush than I expected as a gift. I used to think of Stila as just having pretty but expensive makeup, but with this eyeliner and brush gift, I feel like I got a great deal. You can buy it cheaper online, but the original cost is still on the pricier side... I just hope it doesn't get discontinued or change color. By the way, the Kiss Me dark brown is almost black and really makes the eye makeup look sharp, so if you use it together with the Clio Black pencil liner, it's just perfect. - ki*********Oily SkinSensitive SkinRecommendedJun 1, 2019
The color payoff is the dark brown I wanted, and it's really pretty. Despite being a brush pen ink, there is absolutely no bleeding for a long time, and the brush is also thin, so it draws the lines well when removing them. Since it is waterproof, be sure to use products such as oil or foam to thoroughly remove it during cleansing. - Hwahae UserCombination SkinSensitive SkinAcne SkinRecommendedMar 9, 2019
The painting was well-done and did not bleed. The liquid seemed to have come out completely! It was a bit disappointing that it didn't wash off easily during cleansing.
