{"content_id":"2002688","content_type":"product"}
4.24
57
5
4
3
2
1
13
Reviews
- Hwahae UserCombination SkinAcne SkinMay 30, 2025
The color is a subtle, natural deep brown that looks beautiful. Sometimes when I opened the cap, the liquid would gush out unexpectedly, which was startling. Because of this, I ended up wasting more product than I actually used, which was such a shame. This is the main reason I won't be repurchasing it. - Hwahae UserCombination SkinAcne SkinSensitive SkinApr 9, 2025
This eyeliner is my go-to product - I've used over 3 tubes and have 3 more stashed at home! My mom's used more than 10 tubes, which is how I got hooked on it too. For reference: I'm 21 with a deep undertone, muted (doesn't suit high-chroma orange or yellow). I've only tried the Ash Brown shade. It's not very brown, and the ash tone is lighter than expected - more like a soft black. I'd like to try other brown shades next time. Highly recommend if you like soft black or ashy tones! It works for both warm and cool tones, but I'd especially recommend it for cool complexions. The eyeliner absorbs well and has great staying power. The color and pigmentation are more intense than expected, so I wouldn't recommend it if you're after a natural look. While I liked everything else about it, I've recently been preferring more subtle eyeliners, so the intensity was a bit disappointing for me. - Hwahae UserDehydrated SkinSep 26, 2024
Natural ash brown shade Brush with just the right amount of flexibility Slightly weak staying power on oily skin Ink leakage due to the case design Recommended to use after applying eye primer or setting powder! - Hwahae UserOily SkinAcne SkinSep 20, 2024
I really love the ash color! The ash brown isn't too light, which is great, and it truly gives off that ash brown vibe at first glance. While brush eyeliners can be tricky for those with shaky hands, this product somehow applies beautifully! I'd highly recommend it to beginners - it makes you feel like an eyeliner pro. The line goes on thin, but you can build it up for a thicker look if desired. The color is naturally a bit light, but becomes more vibrant with multiple layers. Even with layering, it doesn't smudge or look messy. Unless you're crying, it won't budge or smear at all! The only issue is that sometimes the liquid leaks during application. I'm not sure if it's just my product that's faulty. - Hwahae UserNormal SkinSensitive SkinSep 3, 2024
The color is a natural and beautiful ash brown, just as described. It might be perfect for those who found other browns too intense! It feels sharper than expected... Those with sensitive eye areas might want to test it before purchasing. - Hwahae UserCombination SkinSensitive SkinAug 24, 2024
The pen is very thin, making it useful for those with hidden double eyelids or thin eyelid creases. It's great for drawing fine lines or dotting along the lash line. The formula is perfect for creating subtle looks. However, be careful not to overdo it, as layering too much can look unnatural. Moderation is key. I'm not a fan of chocolate brown, so I'm quite satisfied with this color. When carried in a makeup pouch, the product's exterior peels off as shown in the photo. This is extremely inconvenient, as the peeled-off powder gets everywhere - on your hands, other products, it's a real mess. Additionally, sometimes liquid suddenly gushes out from the brush pen tip, requiring you to wipe off the excess with a tissue to control the amount. The color is quite dark, almost appearing black at first glance. - Hwahae UserDry SkinDec 12, 2023
I have a lot of skin around my eyes and tend to smile with my eyes, but this is the first eyeliner that doesn't smudge this much. It's incredibly smudge-proof. The color I love most is shade 2, which is a matte, ashy brown. It's a versatile shade that would suit all skin tones, regardless of personal color. The hint of gray gives it a subtly sophisticated look. At first, I thought the eyeliner felt heavy, but as I used it, I found it wasn't uncomfortable. While there were some downsides (mentioned below), the smudge-proof and long-lasting qualities are so impressive that I'll repurchase unless I find something even better. The ink tends to leak. There was a time when it leaked badly, and recently, as soon as I opened the cap, ink exploded everywhere, splattering on my face and surroundings. This happens even though I only use it at home. I'm not sure if I just got a faulty one, but it's disappointing. This is why I'm deducting one star. While this product is sufficient for a complete makeup look on its own, using a pencil liner to draw the overall line and then using this eyeliner to create a sharp, defined tail can subtly elevate your makeup quality. - Hwahae UserDehydrated SkinAcne SkinSensitive SkinNov 5, 2023
It's a brown shade, but with a slight hint of gray, so it's not too yellow or red. I bought it thinking the lighter tone would suit me well, and I'm pleased with it. The brush's elasticity is decent, and it's easy to use for everyday looks. However, if you try to layer it, that specific area becomes darker, making touch-ups a bit tricky. It works well for drawing the outer corners of the eyes though. - Hwahae UserCombination SkinSensitive SkinJun 5, 2023
•Perfect for those who don't suit bold eyeliner. It's brown but not so dark it looks black, making it ideal for shadow-like application. •The case has a nice weight and feels great in hand. •Easy to apply, long-lasting, and doesn't smudge. There's nothing bad to say! I'm so happy I found the perfect shade. It's brown, but not so dark it looks black, nor too light. It's just the right brown.. - Hwahae UserCombination SkinAcne SkinJun 1, 2023
I'm really pleased that it's not as light as I expected for an ash shade - it's even better this way. I was so tired of regular brown, but this ash color seems to complement any eyeshadow look, so I'm very satisfied. The application is smooth, and I love that it doesn't smudge or bleed. There's nothing particularly disappointing about it. I'm using it with satisfaction.