Name: 9 to 9 Survival Penliner Natural [03 Ash Taupe]
Brand: lilybyred
Rating: 4.5 (18 reviews)

Rich and earthy shades like mustard yellow, olive green, and chocolate brown look great on you

How to Write a TikTok Review
 Help us keep the Hwahae community trustworthy by following these guidelines: 
Reviews that violate these may be removed without notice.

Bright and fresh shades like coral, warm pinks, and fresh greens look great on you

Soft and muted shades like pastel blues, dusty pinks, and soft lavenders look great on you

High-contrast and bold shades like pure white, black, icy blues, and deep reds look great on you

I confirm this is my own TikTok video and agree it maybe featured on Hwahae.
 Any misuse may result in removal or restrictions.
 For details, tap the

Our service will be temporarily unavailable during:

Scheduled Maintenance

Each product allows one tiktok video review and one text review

This is a Health Functional Food certified by the Ministry of Food and Drug Safety (MFDS) of Korea, designed to help maintain and improve your health.

This review was written by The Hwahae Testers who received the product for free and evaluated it with a sense of representing Hwahae. The review is completely unbiased and honest, with no guidelines or restrictions.

Reviews by The Hwahae Testers undergo the same strict verification process as regular reviews, and if they don't meet our standards, revisions will be requested.

Each ingredient is selected for its specific purpose, such as improving skin hydration or brightening. However, the inclusion of these ingredients does not guarantee the overall effectiveness of the final product. Simply using these ingredients does not ensure the product will deliver the claimed benefits.

AI-Analyzed Reviews are coming soon!
We're gathering more reviews to provide you with the best insights.

Be the first to share your experience!
Used this product?
Share your TikTok review to help others discover it.

The content is currently being reviewed by the Hwahae operations team, and the verification will be completed by the next business day (excluding weekends and holidays) from the date the review was written.

Help us keep the Hwahae community trustworthy by following these guidelines.
Reviews that don’t follow the standards may be removed without notice.

Reviews that don’t follow the guidelines may be removed without prior notice.

Tell us about what you liked - texture, results, skin type, etc

Tell us what didn’t work - texture, skin reaction, or why you wouldn’t recommend it

릴리바이레드

9 to 9 Survival Penliner Natural [03 Ash Taupe]

Not Olive-Toned

Pills on Skin

Poor Pigmentation

Smudges

Clumps

Smudges Easily

Soft

Recommended for Fall Warm Tones

Lasts Long

Recommended for Warm Tones

Brown-Toned

Looks Natural

Has a Shading Effect

Although you can draw eyeliner using an eyebrow pencil, when you want a more defined look, you would use it.

If the bold eyeliner doesn't suit you, just buy it.

Wow, the Hwahae eyeliner. I've never even used a black eyeliner in my life, being a summer mute whose eye makeup doesn't suit me, but this is the only one I can use. What's with the oily lids, the double eyelid, and eyeliner, you know? But when the eyeliner is too pigmented, it looks really weird, so I tried a lighter one, and wow, the longevity is insane. I've never seen oilier skin than mine, but this is the only eyeliner that truly survives on my eyes. It's really the best.

나인투나인 서바이벌 펜라이너 내추럴 [03 #애쉬토프]

I think Ash Brown might be better. This shade has a yellowish tint, and it's barely noticeable on the skin.

The bottom one is Ash Taupe. It gives a subtle, natural look. I bought it to add some shadow underneath, but it's so sheer that when I try to build it up, it starts looking odd!

I think shade 2 is better formulated than shade 3.

Not ideal for long-term use... Product quality issues

The Lilybyred eyeliner's main flaw: The brush splays out too easily... It seems even worse than Ki*mi, which makes it difficult to use for an extended period. This is really disappointing. Especially towards the end of its life, it feels like the ink is leaking excessively, so I'm unsure about repurchasing.

Natural and delicate eyeliner (+ amazing value for money)

Value for money:
The biggest advantage of this product is undoubtedly its affordability. I purchased it as part of a set at Olive Young for just over 10,000 won. It's rare to find such good value in lighter shades, but this product is exceptionally cheap, making it a top choice for budget-conscious shoppers.

Delicate and natural-looking eyeliner:
As someone who loves a soft, subtle makeup look, I've tried various watered-down eyeliners. This one is my favorite by far. It's easy to apply, and the diluted color creates a beautifully natural effect.

Surprisingly long-lasting and the pigmentation is on point!

There's nothing to complain about! You can draw a natural-looking eyeline with this product.

I've been using the ash brown color, but I needed something more natural, so I bought this. I really like it!

It comes off easily, so if you make a mistake, you can simply wipe it off with your finger and reapply. How convenient!

As someone with thin upper eyelids and horizontally long eyes, bold eyeliner doesn't suit me. But this product is the best! It's perfect for those times when you want a subtle line. It's also incredibly easy to apply.

It tends to smudge or fade as time passes. That's the only downside.

Dry skin type, shade 21, student here. My deep undertone suits muted tones with lower saturation rather than red hues. Lilybyred's Ash Taupe is my holy grail! As someone who doesn't suit heavy eyeliner or intense colors, this is perfect. Application: Absorbs beautifully. Color payoff: It applies evenly without smudging, though it's lighter than expected. Staying power: I'd say it's moderate.

When trying to draw a thicker line, sometimes it feels like the color doesn't fill in as beautifully as desired.

An eyeliner perfect for those who don't suit heavy makeup. You can adjust the intensity of color by layering. The staying power is also decent.

The staying power is almost non-existent when applied close to the eye's mucous membrane

I recommend this for those who prefer subtle color and don't usually wear eyeliner

The color is quite sheer, so it's not very noticeable, but it's still pretty

It's great for a subtle daily look or for creating dimension in your makeup

Like many brush eyeliners, after prolonged use, the bristles can get caught in the cap when closing, causing them to bend and stick out awkwardly.

I bought this because I don't like drawing sharp black eyeliner, and it turned out to be exactly the watered-down brown brush pen liner I wanted. It's not just a diluted brown, but it really captures that 'taupe' essence, which I love. With black liner, you often need to soften it with eyeshadow, but this one allows for a natural look while still defining the eyes beautifully.

I wouldn't recommend this to those who prefer a sharp, high-contrast eyeliner look. It's better suited for people searching for a soft, ashy brown eyeliner.

Despite many reviews saying the color payoff is weak, I found it to be more intense than the Holika Holika Double Eyeliner. While one application might be a bit light, it's perfect when applied over eyeshadow and primer, making my eyes look more defined. I love that you can build it up with 2-3 layers for a deeper color. As someone who doesn't suit heavy eyeliner, I intentionally look for lighter options, and this one makes my eyes look less heavy and more open. It doesn't smudge either, so I'm really satisfied!

Korean Reviews

9 to 9 Survival Penliner Natural [03 Ash Taupe]

2 Reviews