{"content_id":"2040521","content_type":"product"}
4.28
34
5
4
3
2
1
60
Reviews
- lo************Combination SkinRecommendedJun 30, 2025
This is it! This is the one! I'm telling you, this stuff is amazing. I was out in Seoul for hours, and on my way home, my friend took one look at my eyes and asked what I was using! There are absolutely no downsides. Honestly, it's so perfect that it's almost disappointing there's nothing to criticize! - ki******Combination SkinBrightening/Dark SpotsSebum/BlackheadsInner DrynessRednessRecommendedJun 28, 2025
This is the longest-lasting eyeliner I've ever used. There's nothing to complain about. The color is great and it lasts well, so I plan to buy it again. 
na******Dehydrated SkinSebum/BlackheadsRecommendedMay 9, 2025The pink packaging is absolutely fantastic! It applies smoothly without smudging, so I'm really enjoying using it. The price is also reasonable, which is why I'm on my fourth tube. It's a great, reliable choice for everyday use! I can't think of any downsides... While I haven't tried many eyeliners, I honestly can't find anything to complain about with this one! - bo********Dry SkinDark CirclesInner DrynessRecommendedMay 5, 2025
The staying power is absolutely incredible, and it's so long-lasting that even most cleansing products struggle to remove it! It's perfect for those who don't want to touch up their makeup throughout the day. I highly recommend this to anyone with a warm autumn complexion! Due to its thin consistency, I wouldn't recommend this to makeup beginners or those still learning. It's also not ideal for people who prefer a light application of foundation. There's absolutely no need to shake the product before use! In fact, if you do shake it, you might be surprised by how much comes out. - mo***Combination SkinBrightening/Dark SpotsRecommendedApr 8, 2025
It draws on clearly and the color is a nice dark brown. The staying power is excellent. There's absolutely nothing to complain about. It's perfect in every way. - go**********Combination SkinSensitive SkinAcne SkinRecommendedApr 8, 2025
I must have gone through about 20 tubes of this! It's not absolutely smudge-proof, but I haven't found a better product yet, so I keep using it. On days when I apply it cleanly without layering, it barely budges. However, if you layer it, it can crack a bit. Rather than smudging, it tends to fade away into a powder. It cracks when layered, and on days when my skin is particularly oily, it gradually disintegrates into powder. 
yu*****Dry SkinAcne SkinDark CirclesInner DrynessRednessDead Skin CellsRecommendedApr 3, 2025The staying power is excellent. After it sets, it doesn't smudge or fade even when rubbed with fingers. It applies smoothly regardless of line thickness. It doesn't clump, making it user-friendly for beginners practicing with brush pen eyeliners. The pen tip is designed like a ballpoint pen, making it comfortable to hold, unlike some cylindrical ones that can be awkward to grip. When tested on the back of the hand, it applies well even in fine lines and shows minimal cracking. The brown shade was darker than expected. I recommend testing it in-store before purchasing. While it resists rubbing with hands or dry towels, it easily comes off with wet wipes or running water, so for rainy days or water parks, I'd suggest using a waterproof product instead. - cl******Dehydrated SkinSensitive SkinBrightening/Dark SpotsSebum/BlackheadsInner DrynessWrinkles/ElasticityEnlarged PoresRednessDead Skin CellsRecommendedMar 8, 2025
I often have issues with my eyes, and frequent tearing usually causes most eyeliners to wear off quickly. As someone who's been on a quest for the perfect eyeliner due to my teary eyes, this product is the one I've finally settled on! I've used it during fall and winter, so I'm not sure how it holds up against oil and sweat yet. However, when it comes to tears, it has pretty strong staying power! The longevity is impressive - it often lasts all day without needing touch-ups. It even survived a night of drinking and shedding buckets of tears. Just be aware that sometimes it can wear off after half a day. I think this might still be due to tearing, but I'm not sure why the staying power fluctuates. If you've been stressed about poor longevity due to watery eyes, give this a try! While it seems to have strong staying power even against tears, there are times when the longevity fails - possibly due to tearing or some other issue. Because of this, I stopped carrying it with me for a while, but I've started to bring it along again. The best-case scenario is for it not to come off at all, but since it might wear off, it's always a good idea to carry your eyeliner with you. - 89****Dry SkinSensitive SkinDark CirclesInner DrynessRednessDead Skin CellsRecommendedFeb 24, 2025
As someone who usually only uses subtle eyeliners, I was impressed by how pigmented this one is. It would suit those with warm undertones beautifully. Given the nature of eyeliners, some smudging seems unavoidable, unfortunately. Try setting the eyeliner with some powder. This should help reduce smudging and make it last longer. - in*********Dehydrated SkinSebum/BlackheadsDark CirclesInner DrynessEnlarged PoresRecommendedFeb 22, 2025
The Lilybyred 9 to 9 Survival Pen Liner is truly famous for its excellent color payoff and long-lasting formula. I've been using it for a while now, and I find it gets better with each use. As someone with oily eyelids who usually ends up with panda eyes shortly after applying eye makeup, I can attest that this pen liner is a game-changer. It's resistant to both moisture and oil, giving it impressive staying power that doesn't easily smudge from sweat or sebum. I highly recommend this to anyone who struggles with smudging eyeliner. Moreover, the brush is incredibly thin and precise, making it user-friendly even for beginners. It's also great for touch-ups as it doesn't remove the existing line when reapplying. This liner is perfect for those seeking to achieve defined, striking eyes. The product works so well for me that I honestly can't think of any downsides! This eyeliner is so good that it creates beautiful lines without needing any special techniques or tips.
