{"content_id":"1744106","content_type":"product"}
3.99
5
607
4
3
2
1
86
Reviews
- Hwahae UserDehydrated SkinSensitive SkinOct 1, 2022
Unbeatable value for money! I'm convinced you won't find this quality at this price point anywhere else. Excellent staying power! While pencils typically don't last as long due to their nature, this one rivals even brush pen eyeliners in longevity. It might just be the most long-lasting pencil eyeliner on the market! I'm over the moon with satisfaction. The texture is wonderfully smooth. Since it's applied near the eyes, a hard pencil can cause irritation, but this one glides on so smoothly. There's zero irritation, it applies effortlessly, and the smooth application means no skipping or patchiness. It's perfect for creating beautiful lines - highly recommended for beginners! Doesn't dry out easily. One reason people avoid pencils is that they dry out quickly, forcing you to sharpen them and waste product. They become hard and difficult to apply. But this one stays creamy even after extended use. It always applies smoothly without irritation, no matter when you use it. I'm absolutely thrilled with this product! There's nothing bad to say, really... If I had to nitpick, maybe they could make it in a rainbow of colors? Oh, and just a note - the Sienna Brown shade is a lighter brown. Recommended for warm skin tones. For cool tones, I'd suggest Chocolate Brown or Black! I usually just use this on its own, but for even more staying power, try layering it with eyeshadow. Or, use this product as a base and then trace over it with a brush pen eyeliner (I use Woodbury). It becomes absolutely smudge-proof - highly, highly recommended! - Hwahae UserCombination SkinAcne SkinSensitive SkinDec 26, 2020
I bought this after seeing it recommended on YouTube. It glides on smoothly when applied, and the color is a beautiful brown. Even hours after drawing the eyeliner, it absolutely doesn't smudge and stays well-fixed. I'm very satisfied! The price is also incredibly affordable, making it an even more satisfying product. While I liked the slim version, I find the ultra-slim to be even thinner and easier to apply. For all gel eyeliners, you need to set the line with a dark brown eyeshadow to prevent smudging and ensure long-lasting wear. Alternatively, make sure to powder it thoroughly. - Hwahae UserOily SkinAcne SkinOct 31, 2020
I've been using this for 6 years now... As a cosmetics enthusiast, I'm always on the lookout for better products. I've tried various options on the market, but I keep coming back to this one and repurchasing it. It's perfect in terms of both function and price. The thin design makes it convenient to use. It applies smoothly from start to finish without drying out midway. It glides on softly. It doesn't smudge. It comes in a variety of colors. The price is reasonable. As smoothly as it applies, it's prone to breaking in the middle while using it, which happens quite often, unfortunately. For those who say their eyeliner smudges: Try this routine: Finish powder -> Waterproof pencil eyeliner -> Gently pat black or brown eyeshadow over the eyeliner to set it -> Finally, touch up the line with a waterproof brush pen eyeliner. It won't smudge! Don't just use waterproof products alone. Make sure to follow these steps: Powder -> Eyeliner -> Eyeshadow in the same color as the eyeliner -> Brush pen eyeliner. Give it a try! - Hwahae UserCombination SkinSensitive SkinOct 28, 2020
The Saem Eco Soul Power Proof Ultra Slim Eyeliner - Hwahae Testers Review 1. What I loved most was the creamy texture. It glides on smoothly while still having excellent adherence. 2. The slim design makes it great for precise application. 3. Lastly, I tested its waterproof claim by drawing on my hand and rinsing with water - it truly lives up to its waterproof promise! It comes off easily with eye makeup remover though. The only drawback for me personally was that the color was a bit light. In the fourth photo, the rightmost swatch is The Saem product. It was lighter than I prefer as someone who usually uses dark brown, but I'm sure they've released other shades as well. As many of you may know, applying eyeshadow over your eyeliner can improve its longevity and create a beautiful layered effect with complex colors. Shimmery eyeshadows look pretty too! - Hwahae UserNormal SkinOct 27, 2020
When I first applied it, I was pleased that the formula wasn't stiff but spread smoothly! Some other slim eyeliners can be quite hard, probably to prevent breakage due to their thinness. This often leads to a sharp feeling and irritation at the corner of the eyes when first using them. However, this product glides on softly from the start, and I've never experienced it breaking while using it, which is great. As someone whose makeup doesn't usually stay put easily, I found the lasting power to be impressive. If I had to point out one drawback, it's that the tip becomes a bit blunt with use, making it challenging to draw sharp lines. - Hwahae UserCombination SkinOct 27, 2020
The Hwahae Testers review✨ Overall: Easy to use due to its thin and soft texture, with excellent staying power and water resistance. Great value among ultra-slim eyeliners! ▫️Feel: It's noticeably softer than other products! 'Creamy' would be the right word to describe it. While it's true that softer and slimmer eyeliners are generally better, I've had issues with other products breaking too easily. This one, however, doesn't have that problem, so I'm using it well. ▫️Waterproof: It obviously doesn't come off with water. You'd have to scrub hard to remove it. I tend to tear up at the corners of my eyes, but this eyeliner holds up well against those tears! ▫️Staying power: Given its resistance to tears and water, it naturally has good staying power. What's most satisfying is that despite its creamy, hydrating feel, it doesn't develop that typical eyeliner cracking at the corners of the eyes, even after a long time. ▫️Value for money: Eyeliner seems to be the makeup product we use up the fastest, so price is important. I kept twisting to see how much product there was, and it's quite long! I was too scared to twist it all the way out, but at 8000 won, I think it's excellent value compared to other famous ultra-slim products. While the staying power is good, I use an eyelash curler after applying eyeliner, and I noticed that the liner on the waterline comes off quite a bit during this process. But that seems unavoidable, and there are no other downsides to this product. - Hwahae UserCombination SkinAcne SkinOct 26, 2020
It glides on so thin and smooth! I'd heard this product was popular but never had the chance to try it. My eyes tend to make eyeliners smudge, so I didn't have high hopes for a pencil liner. But wow, was I pleasantly surprised! It goes on smoothly with one swipe, adheres instantly without smudging, and most importantly, creates such a clean line. I love it! Being 2mm ultra-slim, you can draw super fine lines! I used to only use sharpened pencil liners before, but I didn't like how thick they went on. This one's so thin, it's easy to use. I might ditch my gel liners for good! Tip: lay it flat for an even thinner line, or use it upright for a thicker one. I absolutely, 100% recommend this! There's hardly anything to complain about, but when I deliberately drew thick lines multiple times for my review photo and rubbed it vigorously with my finger, it smudged slightly. However, you wouldn't do this when actually applying it to your eyes, so I believe it will provide the desired waterproof performance during normal use. When drawing your eyeliner, they say it looks best if you start from the highest point above your pupil and then work your way outwards on both sides! - Hwahae UserCombination SkinAcne SkinSensitive SkinOct 26, 2020
First off, I was amazed by how incredibly soft it felt when I tested it on the back of my hand! I've tried many eyeliners of this thickness, but thinner ones are often quite hard, probably because they're prone to breaking. However, The Saem Eco Soul Power Proof Super Slim Eyeliner glides on so effortlessly! I highly recommend it to anyone who wants to create different eye looks daily or draw curved lines that suit their eye shape. I also did a smudge test after about 10 minutes and honestly... it just doesn't smudge... at all. I rubbed it vigorously with my fingers, and nothing came off - I was actually a bit shocked! I was so impressed that I even applied a rich cream on top (sorry, no photo), but even with intense rubbing, there was barely any smudging. I've used many eyeliners, but frankly, this one takes the cake for both smudge-proof quality and smooth application. I used to buy other brands on sale without much thought, but now I'm sticking with The Saem. It's not called Power Proof for nothing! To add a bit more, I think this eyeliner is thin enough and applies well! Of course, there are even thinner products on the market, but those tend to break easily and don't apply as smoothly. I really, really love this eyeliner from The Saem! While the longevity and application were great, the one thing that disappointed me was the color. It's brown, but with a slightly reddish tint. I ended up using this eyeliner as a guideline and then going over it with another eyeliner! Maybe it's because I have cool-toned skin (shade 17-19), but the redness was quite noticeable, which was a bit disappointing. I was surprised to see many reviews saying this eyeliner smudges... Even when I use mascaras known for their staying power (like those from K*ss Me or Ma*belline), I always end up with raccoon eyes, so I never dared to use mascara on my lower lashes. But this eyeliner didn't smudge at all, even on my problematic eyes! For those who experience a lot of smudging, you might want to try setting the eyeliner with some powder after application - that could help prevent smudging. - Hwahae UserCombination SkinOct 25, 2020
Ultra-slim Power Proof: As someone who primarily enjoys pencil makeup for daily wear, I find that while it's called 'ultra-slim', the thickness isn't crucial if you have some skill. However, the slim design definitely makes it easier to draw lines without much thought, reducing the chances of messing up. The best part? It's incredibly soft! Even though gel types usually cause some irritation around the eyes, this one glides on smoothly with minimal irritation, making it great for lining. The color is a vibrant brown for me - perfect for everyday use! Power Proof: Usually, pencil types tend to smudge on me no matter what. Even with powder, the outer corners always disappear! Of course, my habit of touching my eyes doesn't help... But this product showed significantly less smudging around the eyes even without powder. While my outer corner lines still didn't survive due to my habits, the under-eye line smudged less. For cleansing, I used an all-in-one (foaming cleanser) and it removed easily, so I couldn't really feel the 'power proof' aspect. But since the under-eye line didn't smudge much, it's definitely a long-lasting product! I'll pass on commenting about the cleansing aspect. Overall, I found it impressive that despite its smooth application, it has good staying power and is easy to remove (at least for me). If the price is right, I'd definitely repurchase! (And the price is indeed reasonable!) Well... Smudging seems to be the biggest challenge for Power Proof eyeliners. For me, while there was less smudging, it was surprisingly easy to remove - almost like a washable formula. I'll need to test this a few more times to see if it's due to my cleansing product. When I applied it to my hand without oil control and immediately tried to remove it, it came off easily. After some time, about half of it came off when I rubbed it. Since I don't rub my eye area as vigorously as the back of my hand, I'd say it passes considering how lightly I rubbed! However, I've experienced waterproof products that were hard to remove even with vigorous rubbing but still prone to smudging. So it seems that ease of removal and staying power might be different things. - Hwahae UserCombination SkinAtopy SkinSensitive SkinOct 25, 2020
The application feels incredibly smooth, which I really love. While I haven't tried many gel eyeliners, among those I've used, this one absorbs well and quickly sets to a matte finish, which is great. It feels like you get what you pay for with this budget-friendly option. The tendency of gel eyeliners to apply thicker and require angled application is unavoidable. However, the price point is perfect for eyeliner beginners to practice without breaking the bank!